Are you sure they heard?
I wonder how many players hated Josy and Maya after that?
if they were not looking for excuses the reasons are previous.
that, however, remains a very poorly thought out scene by DPC.
This scene doesn't make sense to me considering that Josy and Maya confess their love for each other, and then Josy keeps stalking MC and saying she thinks about him and wishes Maya would disappear. It's weird. In ep 5 she accuses MC of not choosing her and just backing off. This all shows Josy in a bad light. It's common to blame Maya, but no one pays attention to the fact that Josy is a coward and doesn't know what she wants at all.
That was my first play though. I was kinda whoring it up, but didn't expect to be shot down by the girls in that scene, so I was kinda like, "Oh fuck!", but then I was like, "Next!"
I didn't really see it at the time as the girls being totally insensitive and rubbing the mc's nose in their rejection of him, but in hindsight, just looking at that screenshot, it looks pretty fucking insensitive.
But, from the girls' perspective, it was a pretty tough few days (I don't really have a clue how long it was but I'm going with a few days). Both of them cared about the mc and weren't intending to just use him as a distraction, they kinda started to fall for him (and Josy still isn't over him).
That whole scene took a lot of guts from everyone involved. They all had to confront their own cheating (neither Josy nor Maya were aware until that scene that the other had cheated on them). I still love the look on Josy's face when the mc just comes out and tells Maya that Josy and he had fucked!
You can almost read her mind, "What the fuck dude!!
"
But anyway, at that very moment, they found out they had been cheated on and then the mc either suggested they try making it work, or just stay friends. Either way, the girls came to terms with being cheated on (a bit hypocritical not to since they were both as guilty - Josy slightly more, because coitus interruptus is still coitus
), and even with the mc walking away, they still had each other, so I guess that's why they started making out. Plus, both those dresses are totally make out dresses, no restrictions whatsoever!
when MC tells Bella his story in the first version of the game it was possible that he and Zoey had had underage sex, then it is rectified (by decreasing the time MC and Zoey separated) so that the sex scene in the treehouse is safe.
However, this actually upsets the whole story between the 2 a bit (Zoey practically asks MC to leave school a few months before it ends normally, MC after crying in the rain over Zoey quickly gets over it and falls in love with Josy...)
I'm happy to give DPC a pass on that. We know they fucked as high school kids, lets just allow Patreon to feel safe and know the truth in our hearts.