What does not really fit Sage's personality (sex crazed nympho that wants constantly to have sex) is her dating a full gay (Chad) for so long. She jumps on MC's cock 5 minutes after she sees him, and I have to believe she did not fuck anyone else in a campus full of horny dudes, while keeping a sex-less relation with Chad?
The problem with main girls of this game is that they are not believable, not realistic. Lesbians, virgins, widow Sport Illustrated babe that had vow of chastity, horny bombshell dating a gay.
The story was always meant to be more light-hearted than other AVNs who take things more seriously, so some crazy unbelievable scenarios were meant to be expected. Some things, despite looking ridiculous at first, could have some plausible explanations, though:
- Despite her nature, Sage tried her hardest to be a good gf to Chad and repress herself. It's finally when she's sure Chad is cheating that she decides to jump onto Tremolo, who seems more chill and just happens to be better looking that the average guys around campus (Cause MC has to be the most handsome one). She's also not stupid, so she'd never be too crazy to fuck someone like Derek no matter how desperate she was. She might be a Nympho, but she can be picky and smart.
- Jossy and Maya just happen to be the fantasy many men have: Not only being in a throple, but kinda 'changing the mind' of girls who only liked other girls before, but since you're different 'you're the exception'. Found that a tad unrelistic, but as a lesbian myself (and I'm not like M&J in any way), I got to meet many female friends who claimed to be lesbian (like Maya), but they were actually bi all the time but terrified of men for some reason. And also met openly bi girls like Jossy who happen to be the stereotype of 'since I'm bi I can date both a guy and a girl at the same time, and I wish they were cool with it!'. People like this exist, DPC just happened to put all this together, and M&J was born.
- The only thing I struggle to believe with the Virgin is that
she's also rich, while being beautiful, kind and having a guarding dog shooing away anyone with bad intentions. I've personally known women in their early 20s who were beautiful (like REALLY gorgeous), dorkish and were still virgins. They weren't filthy rich though, and they didn't have a Bella guarding them.
- Bella, Cathy and Jade are the ones I struggle to find 'realistic'. Their attraction might be more understandable with a CHIK, but when Tremolo is a full DIK, I can't see how or why... but again, this is one of the cases were DPC created them based in a regular fantasy: Who didn't fantasize about fucking one of out hot teachers? Funny thing, is the way the behave and their whole persona are actually quite belieavable and normal, but it's the way that they feel instant attraction to Tremolo that reminds us this is just a VN.
This are just some examples of some of the characters you mentioned, though we still have the rest of the HOTs, Nicole and the other girls, etc. The beauty of this AVN is that it has belieavble characters with believable reactions and behaviors, but the situations they find themselves in are simply fantastic and ridiculous to let us live the fantasy of being a young attractive MC, while still dealing with potential partners that feel like actual people and not midnless fuckdolls.