OK I have a question regarding the theory about Jacob being the traitor. If you convince Derek to not fuck Arieth with him, what leverage would he have for trying to pin the blame on MC for sending the pictures to the jocks? Not to mention there's no way MC could have taken the pictures of the others fucking her, he was barely a pledge at that point. I don't think the traitor could be Jacob cuz from a point that'd intersect with any and all choices previously made, but you know who I'm most sus of, besides Nick?
TOMMY
That scumsucker has plenty of reason to hate you in every route, moreso if you're a sisterfucker. Think about it. New blood comes in and starts "taking control". He leads the restoration project, wants them to volunteer at the elderly house, convinces Rusty to stop relying on his father's money and actually become a reliable leader instead of a party fiend, etc. Not to mention, Tommy could potentially show flagrant disregard to the DIK secrecy code, both with Derek's video and your own calling of it over your relationship with Maya and Josy and Tommy ignored it immediately, unlike Nick who seems to have kept his mouth shut over seeing Bella leave in the morning.
Again, I'm not a smart lad or nothing, this is just me spitballing. I know there's probably holes in my theory, but it's no worse than "Jacob is always there and a nice guy and no one is that nice" or "The laptop was in the library, Nick is found in the library so why didn't he find the laptop, also he's Vinny's DIK brother so he could be an insider" etc and so on. Lemme know y'alls thoughts on this.
