Darkwen

Conversation Conqueror
Nov 10, 2020
6,512
12,720
I have already pointed out the following a few times in the past.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Josy made it sound like that's because she doesn't like to spend time with her mom Iris and she doesn't like Clive her mom new guy. Like Maya I think Josy endure some kind of abuse when she was younger maybe when she was older too perhaps face bullying as well, it would account for her internal conflict and would help explain how Josy and Maya happen
 

Bad Wolf

Devoted Member
Jul 17, 2021
9,254
14,247
In general, nobody likes ex-girlfriends. Everyone has bad memories. Then the developers throw them into the mix in the middle of the story which doesn't help them. For me Zoey had a good start, however it's 2 times that she talks to mc and still hasn't said anything at all, leaving only mc to open up, thus creating 2 more pathetic moments. Very disappointing her role in this chapter, perhaps the worst of all
I can't disagree. But then we have her scene where she realized that she loved the MC and it broke her. That was the scene where she ran off and cried.
 

ChipLecsap

Conversation Conqueror
Aug 4, 2019
7,616
27,199
Imo even if you dont have any interrest in the a zoey-path, her inclusion is good story-telling and a possibility for the mc to get closure.
No because she was an afterthought for 8 episode. In acting lesson, you start the Game with a Damaged MC wounded by his EX . In badik, Zoey was nothing but a brief flashback, overall, she had zero affect on MC for 8 episode.

and when the players finally had the chance to get the chosen love interest, dpc instead of continue the story give us a useless episode about an Ex-girlfriend, whos whole story during San-diego could have been and btw it was, dealt with in one conversation on the bench between MC and Zoey.
 
  • Like
Reactions: felicemastronzo

Krytax123

Engaged Member
Dec 29, 2022
2,812
6,017
Yeah... I felt like the MC realized that: Either Zoey didn't know the answer or Zoey didn't care because she was going to San Diego anyway. That's why he lost his patience, got up and left.
Come on, thats not what happened at all. Its was obvious how he completly caught her off guard with his very emotional and open words.

A guy she has feelings for and was her first love while they never had a defined relationship telling her that she was his first love and he did considered her his future is fucking overwhelming.

The last time she was in a situation like that with the mc (at the train station) he behaved like a little whiny bitch not being able to speak his mind and now he's casually saying something like that. He kinda said: If you would have stayed, i would have married you and we would have shared our lives together.

Thats not something easygoing, has a lot of meaning and is deeply emotional. Its obvious that she would have stayed seeing her reaction, it was like a revelation for her.

And the mc didnt lost his patience, he got (too) emotional which could have ruined the party for him and therefore did cut the conversation off.
 
Last edited:

saynotoNTR

Well-Known Member
Mar 17, 2021
1,272
2,629
Come on, thats not what happened at all. Its was obvious how he completly caught her off guard with his very emotional and open words.
And the mc didnt lost his patience, he got (too) emotional which could have ruined the party for him and therefore did cut the conversation off.
Would Zoey give up on going to San Diego if the MC said he was in love with her? Because from what was shown, Zoey only realized that she was in love (and still is) with the MC only at the end of episode 10.

Zoey herself at Interlude said that she didn't like talking about feelings and that the MC was a bit of a softie. I don't think Zoey would give up on going to San Diego because the MC declared himself to her.
 

Bad Wolf

Devoted Member
Jul 17, 2021
9,254
14,247
But these are all things that only we players know. Which adds to the frustration
Exactly. But most seem to think that Zoey is irredeemable. I don't. When she left the MC, she couldn't see the big picture. All she saw was the little one. Keeping her promise to her grandma. Now, she's reflecting back and seeing the impact of that.
 

Krytax123

Engaged Member
Dec 29, 2022
2,812
6,017
No because she was an afterthought for 8 episode. In acting lesson, you start the Game with a Damaged MC wounded by his EX . In badik, Zoey was nothing but a brief flashback, overall, she had zero affect on MC for 8 episode.

and when the players finally had the chance to get the chosen love interest, dpc instead of continue the story give us a useless episode about an Ex-girlfriend, whos whole story during San-diego could have been and btw it was, dealt with in one conversation on the bench between MC and Zoey.
It doesnt have to be the highest level of drama like with ana in al. It would be lame if the mc would be really damaged about zoey's depature, but it was one of his bigger life-experiences.

And in his talks with maya and bella early in the avn and during his talk with sage in the rain after the chad breakup it was made clear that he didnt got the closure he needed. And now we have the possibility for that and (probably) can even decide how we feel about her actions ourself (like being mad).

And i think its a great tool to show the mc's character development kinda through zoey's eyes, he grew so much since the last time they saw each other. A timid boy turned into a confident leader who isnt afraid to speak his mind or being rejected, being able to show a new level of maturity.

And she was like a tool to show us (a little bit) more of mc's earlier life, it is still kinda strange that he dont seem to have any friends before college or any other personal connections, so she helped fleshing him out a bit.
 

felicemastronzo

Message Maven
May 17, 2020
12,050
23,019
Come on, thats not what happened at all. Its was obvious how he completly caught her off guard with his very emotional and open words.

I guy she has feelings for and was her first love while they never had a defined relationship telling her that she was his first love and he did considered her his future is fucking overwhelming.

The last time she was in a situation like that with the mc (at the train station) he behaved like a little whiny bitch not being able to speak his mind and now he's casually saying something like that. He kinda said: If you would have stayed, i would have married you and we would have shared our lives together.

Thats not something easygoing, has a lot of meaning and is deeply emotional. Its obvious that she would have stayed seeing her reaction, it was like a revelation for her.

And the mc didnt lost his patience, he got (too) emotional which could have ruined the party for him and therefore did cut the conversation off.
It is Zoey who asks him to tell her how he felt, and she could not hope for a better answer, so why should she be in trouble? What did she think he would answer her?


But surely an escape into the woods will help make up for lost time
 

ffive

Devoted Member
Jun 19, 2022
8,217
19,563
But surely an escape into the woods will help make up for lost time
She is only doing the exact thing MC has done like 10 minutes earlier. If you're going to complain, complain about both of them.

(also, trying to make up for lost time by approaching person who just ran away from you isn't the wisest course of action, and some would no doubt complain about how pushy she is being and doesn't respect MC's feelings)
 

Krytax123

Engaged Member
Dec 29, 2022
2,812
6,017
Would Zoey give up on going to San Diego if the MC said he was in love with her? Because from what was shown, Zoey only realized that she was in love (and still is) with the MC only at the end of episode 10.

Zoey herself at Interlude said that she didn't like talking about feelings and that the MC was a bit of a softie. I don't think Zoey would give up on going to San Diego because the MC declared himself to her.
I think she would have stayed but yeah we dont know that (yet) we will get this answer in the future.
I think Zoey was suppressing her feelings at this time in general due to grief but they both were kinda oblivious about their feelings at this point when she left.

I mean the mc is still a bit of a softie lol yet she was and still obviously is into him.

But expressing your feelings to a girl you like usually helps if she likes you too, he didnt even tried to fight for her (to stay), its hard to say if you could have changed an outcome when youre not even trying.

Maybe she would have the same revelation from ep10 at the train station already, maybe she was too hurt/grieving at this point or really didnt loved him, we will see.
 

ChipLecsap

Conversation Conqueror
Aug 4, 2019
7,616
27,199
Exclusive :
The MainGirl Band wrote a Song to Zoey::cool:


" Sorry, girl, but you missed out
Well, tough, luck that boy's mine now
We are more than just good friends
This is how the story ends
Too bad that you couldn't see
See the man that boy could be
There is more that meets the eye

I see the soul that is inside "

MainGirlBand.jpg
:ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO:
 

KАRАMBA

Engaged Member
Jan 6, 2021
3,231
10,134
I don't think Zoey would give up on going to San Diego because the MC declared himself to her.
Of course she would have left anyway.
Because she didn't respect MC.
She didn't think it necessary to say a few words to him.
It's ok with fleeting lovers, but it's not ok do that to someone with whom has been linked for a long time by friendship.
It's disrespectful.
And now she appreciates him only because she sees how popular he is with girls.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: saynotoNTR

felicemastronzo

Message Maven
May 17, 2020
12,050
23,019
She is only doing the exact thing MC has done like 10 minutes earlier. If you're going to complain, complain about both of them.
It is Zoey who came back from San Diego to mend the relationship, not MC. MC may not want to talk about it, that's why Zoey came back. They are not in the same position at all

Instead after hearing how important she was to him she runs away and doesn't answer his message, which is kind of the specialty of the house.
 

Darkwen

Conversation Conqueror
Nov 10, 2020
6,512
12,720
Fixed it for you, my illiterate friend :KEK:

A remix of your old poem, for today's relevance :KEK:
Well that got dark fast I wouldn't quit my day job if I where you. But here one just for you
Josy is sweet Josy is great
Your poems stink
Like Madame Roses toes

Alady
:ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:
 

saynotoNTR

Well-Known Member
Mar 17, 2021
1,272
2,629
She is only doing the exact thing MC has done like 10 minutes earlier. If you're going to complain, complain about both of them.

(also, trying to make up for lost time by approaching person who just ran away from you isn't the wisest course of action, and some would no doubt complain about how pushy she is being and doesn't respect MC's feelings)
But it was Zoey who decided to go after the MC to try to restore her friendship with him and not the MC. If Zoey isn't ready to deal with this situation and run the risk of hearing things she doesn't want to hear, why did she come back? It's not time for Zoey to run, it's her time to impose herself.
 

Krytax123

Engaged Member
Dec 29, 2022
2,812
6,017
It is Zoey who asks him to tell her how he felt, and she could not hope for a better answer, so why should she be in trouble? What did she think he would answer her?


But surely an escape into the woods will help make up for lost time
She is emotional overwhelmed imo and i dont think she expected him to say something like that and with such an openness and confidence.

She probably expected something like he considered her his girlfriend but talking so easily about love and a future together? Thats something entirely different.

And he didnt talked about his feelings nowadays, so why would it be the perfect answer for her? He told her how he felt back than, so the obvious fear from zoey is that he doesnt feels like that anymore and that she missed her chance of a lifetime with her first love.

Their roles are kinda switched now, he's open and able to speak his mind without much troubles and without any fear or being rejected while she's the one now in fear of rejection which hurts even more knowing he wanted to share his life with her at some point in the past.

Would you have prefered her having an emotional breakdown in the camp? The mc having to worry about her state instead of spending time with his li?

Getting away from the party to sort her feelings out was considerate behavior from her, and just look how much hate josy gets for showing emotions in front of him ..
 
Oct 9, 2021
54
153
Exclusive :
The MainGirl Band wrote a Song to Zoey::cool:


" Sorry, girl, but you missed out
Well, tough, luck that boy's mine now
We are more than just good friends
This is how the story ends
Too bad that you couldn't see
See the man that boy could be
There is more that meets the eye

I see the soul that is inside "

View attachment 3190124
:ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO:
Sigh... And of course Maya is the drummer... That girl really can't catch a break!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pax Draconis
4.70 star(s) 1,680 Votes