- May 17, 2020
- 11,789
- 22,749
if you like pathetic scenes there's nothing wrong with that, lots of people like them. it's just a genreThere's no pathetic drama here.
This is a script move that shows the character's double bottom. Most of the time we see Derek, a cheerful and reckless guy, such a typical Stifler from teenage school comedies. Derek is a comedic relief and his task is to amuse the player.
But here strange things begin, it seems like we see that he is a complete idiot, but at other moments suddenly reasonable thinking awakens in Derek - dude is cunning, pulling off various schemes with his studies, and behaves consciously about Throuple relationships, stops following the image of a chatterbox. Something doesn't add up.
This is described quite cleverly in Ep. 10 - we can find the answer in Sage/MC's (Sage route) dialogue at the party when they discuss Maya's family: “I don’t know about Maya, but Derek seems to dull the pain with jokes and stupid things. I joke about it too, and it helps me.”
Derek is not a stupid idiot. This is his mind's defense mechanism. He found how to distract himself from the nightmare in which he lives, so as not to burn out. People are always trying to distract themselves from the bad things. Some people can’t stand it and fall into drug addiction and alcoholism, some find a hobby that helps them distance themselves, some behave unusually, Derek protects his mind with humor and stupid antics. Quite humanly and everything fell into place.
I don't see any problem here. MC being on Quinn's route is not going to harm Maya in any way, just like Quinn, who was the object of trolling on her part, but real harm? No. And Quinn is now completely neutral towards Maya, they act towards each other as if they don't exist, which is good.
And secondly, how does Derek know about this? MC didn't tell Derek that he and Quinn have become close, well, I see a problem here out of nowhere.
but what you wrote has nothing to do with what I was saying, the point is not the depth of Derek's character or how he deals with grief, but that saying he's only at BR because of Maya is a totally exaggerated and not believable statement. during hell week was he defending Maya? Derek is enjoying the fun part of college like everyone does and occasionally gives his sister a look.
I don't give much importance to the issue of sending MC to Maya's room because it's due to plot necessity. but a brother who is so worried about his sister shouldn't send a guy he just met to live with her. however you are wrong about saying that MC's affinity/behaviour has no effect on Maya, apart from the possible heartache, MC's behaviour towards Patrick can be decisive in the outcome of the mission to their home. so if Maya at the end of chapter 10 doesn't have the loan documents it's MC's fault. but again, this is the least important aspect because it's related to plot issues.