Why can't you perceive information about the characters in a more straightforward way and looking everywhere for a trick, deception or a double, no, triple bottom? What's the point of that? Yes, sometimes characters hide something (Bella), and in general it's hard to understand what's going on there and what happened in the past, but why all these fantasies about Josy that she knew MC for months, spied on him, etc.? How the fuck can she track down a random dude in Rooster if she doesn't "stalking" him? We know that MC doesn't publish much, mostly reads. It starts to change somehow only after coming to college.
With the number of theories that you put into each character - no endings will be enough to unravel such a tangle. And it just doesn't make any sense. Even the dark AL was more than straightforward, why do you perceive BADIK differently? BADIK is larger and extensive on all levels - primary, secondary and background characters, more developed and multiply storylines and choices. But why you turn a teen drama-comedy into some kind of mystical thriller or whatever?
Sometimes I think you are just oversized and FAT troll. Sometimes I think you're write something like in quote above, while being on shrooms or something. And when I think that you're seriously believe in what you write and theorize about - I'm scared
All these beards, DPC used it once, now you exaggerating and dragging it EVERYWHERE. Maya used Steve (!!!), they all fooled MC, seen him, know him, all pretend that they don't knew and seen him. O-M-G. Stop it. Do you really want DPC to realize such of your theories and fantasies on a practice or what? Or you at least expect it? Just curious.
View attachment 3346055
Hell, if you don't share with Josy about Chad & Troy she will not use the "beard" term and will not come up with this idea for Thanksgiving. It breaks all your whole theory and conception. If someone "used to" use something, then such person doesn't need any trigger or reminder to use it - beard in our case. If she used it already - she will continue to use it, if she realized it for the first time and found interesting - she will try to use it.
Maya tried to date guys before Josy, and her "interest" in Josy is her escape of failed attempts with guys and school bulling in overall. Their whole backstory with Josy is a separation which Patrick caused and that distanced them from each other. What guys Maya dated for "beard" and fooling Patrick? How the fuck she would able to, while being bullied?
Which one of these? They are optionable for Rooster on both old and new phones and made with intention to reflect MC affinity as well:
View attachment 3346109
View attachment 3346110
View attachment 3346111
View attachment 3346127
View attachment 3346128
View attachment 3346129
Do you get that narrative sometimes doesn't have to match with graphics so blatantly? Especially with the virtual feature like phone inside the game (which is also a virtual thing).
Josy is using the photo she took at their first date for MC contacts photo on her phone. MC is using Josy's photo she took at their first date and sent to him later. Why she used this photo if she had that mysterious "old Rooster MC photo" that she "stealed" while stalking the MC almost 1 year ago?
View attachment 3346170
View attachment 3346263
So, it's mostly you, who look for the problems everywhere.
Because she doesn't stalking him or watching THAT hard. Because he would have noticed if she was staring at him and tracking what he was driving in and out of. It's one thing to pay attention to where he's looking while working on the trading floor - whether he's looking at her or not, and it's another thing to literally chase him. Noticing where a man's gaze is directed is literally an innate ability of women, it's at the level of reflexes. This is something that we usually don't notice when we stare at women and think we're doing it unnoticeably, but they notice it perfectly well. You refute your theory and prove why Josy didn't know anything about the MC bike.
MC admitted that he developed a crush on her and she confessed that she knew how he stared at her and she liked his gazes on her. What the sense of comedy with bike and pretending she wasn't knew if she really did?
View attachment 3346311
Not refuted? Well, imagine that there are iron bars of logic and common sense, so your theories don't seep or pass through them, but you just push these bars apart the way you want and you don't see any problems in this. Doppelgangers, twins, stalking someone for months, etc, it's all beyond the bounds of a normal plot and a decent game. But you insist and want it to be realized this way or another. I get it this way. Because building such crazy theories means that you awaiting their implementation from DPC, or there is no sense of bringing and building all those theories.
View attachment 3346393
You don't get it or fucking with me just for lulz? I already suggested you to make a Jill + J&M playthrough. OR. You can make a PURE Jill playthrough (but you don't want to and that's why I find this argue senseless). So, J&M won't cure MC with cucumber juices, but he still will be clean. It's just ridiculous to discuss or take it seriously.
The ONLY sexual contact you are not able to do being with J&M and/or Jill is Sandy. And I'm pretty sure it was discussed dozens number of times in the past. I mean theories about STDs and so on.
MC fucks Josy in the pool, yeah. Water friction, washing out the natural vagina lubricant, MCs dick bigger than averages ones, and Josy is petite and so on. And there may be a lot of chlorine in the pool water - many people have an allergic reaction to it, even just from contact with such water, here we are talking about sex and very delicate areas of the body. When you have gonorrhea or similar shit it doesn't matter in water you or not, it will always inflict a feeling of discomfort.
You're mixing optional scenes/events with the canon ones (for a particular path/branch). So, if MC is not going to Josy in EP7 and spent his time with Maya or didn't came to either of them, why would Josy still trying to "cure" him with cucumber juice episode later? You can even reject all sex with them after EP5 except fake threesome and the next forced one will be in a swim and spa hot tub with this fucking cucumber coctail.
Josy and Maya knew MC had and STD and secretly "curing" him with cucumber juices mixed with medicine, but it wasn't enough or haven't worked! So, then Josy secretly fetches him a drink from a Derek's bar (yeah, being drunk as hell herself) and probably it works out this time, maybe not, stay tuned. Jesus fucking christ...
You can't help but realize that it's impossible to take you seriously after that, no?
Or he would not! EP2 / EP5 Josy scenes are both optional and he never cum inside her. In EP2 they are getting interrupted and in EP5 he splattered her face. The first time she mentioning that she is back to the pills is a pool scene in HOTs (also optional). And if she got pregnant that time we talking about (EP2-EP5), she would have got a pretty good belly in the EP10 already. Since we are following her words in EP10 about abortions. Same goes for Sage. Josy and other MGs and SGs are not Arieth.
The game runs on an RenPy engine (code) and in order for your choices to make sense, it remembers them in the form of variables. If game doesn't remember some choice, then it's a dummy, or you can't make an influence on it and building theories doesn't make sense, because in this case, the author's will is entirely over everything. I'm not saying that code is a panacea, but you can't deny the obvious facts. That somehow you can be tracked, punished or rewarded for previous choices only if the game remembers them.
Sometimes it feels like talking to the tree or something... You don't
STEAL money during free roams. You
COLLECT them. Their locations are even mentioned in the official guide. The case with Jill is the only one that considered as "stealing the money" and MC don't take them immideately - you getting the choice - to take or leave it as is. If you take them - you set the variable to True and game remembers it. No variables are saved in any other places and cases of taking (collecting) the money. Your fantasies about consequences are senseless, because you can't be checked for doing that. Even more. Since Seasons 1-2 and 3 are separated - we have to transfer our saves. You can check yourself what variables game transfers into the Season 3 and which one discards forever. For the sake to save your time and not to build senseless theories based only on your imagination.
DPC don't want player to collect money, I get ya. And the only way to play right is with mini-games. Fuck DPC's words of gameplay equality. You know everything better than he does. Fine.
Finished writing all this and thought, tf what for I did that?
View attachment 3346558