Roger-a-Dale

Member
May 9, 2024
368
527
i always hated this stupid thing in the game, if Jill dont invite mc to sushi with her friends and you choose fight for Jill, than mc overchoose the player and just dont go to restaurant when tybalt ask she to marry, because... well there is absolute no reason and 0 logic... it is just stupid.
Maya and Jojo got a normal scene where they reject the mc if dik, but Jill not.
ps: i know, if mc as dik, go to the restaurant, Jill reject him, but as i know, you can only go there, if you was with her sushi. but if you dont get invitation to sushi, you cant go to restaurant so you wont get any rejection. so this is kind of optional
dpc just broke down Jill and Sage for me with this forcing friendzoned Jill and forcing more than duckbuddy Sage
Well Jill's path is to my mind the weakest story, but the way I see it the implied explanation is this: Jill has bad experiences with dating. Unless you go the extra miles for her, she doesn't dare to properly trust you. A lot of Jill's stuff can be explained by her relying too much on first impressions and having a bit warped view on bullying. Jill is appalled by violence, but doesn't recognise the dangers of psychological and financial attacks. If you are too aggressive physically, Jill will be a bit too afraid of that aspect of you, but she can't spot Tybalt for what he is.

That's how I make sense of that to myself, but all in all it makes her kinda too demanding for my tastes. Initially I hoped her story would be of a good sheltered girl rebelling with a bad boy and I still hope it turns into that, but the good girl taming the bad boy angle her path seems to be now is not my thing.

But the two big things I can't stand with her are. 1. Not letting the MC take care of Sage when she is sick. It's the most CHICK thing you can do in the entire game and Jill won't have it. 2. The damn banana.

Seriously it would make way more sense for Sage to be too mad at us over that choice, but she is so forgiving.

Sage > Jill
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,170
21,831
i see your point, but if the player as full dik try to being on Jill path, than it is very idiot move... and mc should not know about Jill will reject him or not
edit: i mean, (as full dik ) be on Jill route and not going to restaurant is a idiot move
I understood what you meant. but I think in the end it's better that way. because you're right that an MC DIK should still go to Jill if he cares about her, but then how should he react? because if you don't then give me the opportunity to react differently I'd rather just skip certain appointments.

if you want to from a roleplay point of view imagine that even Mc has realized that Jill is not for him in the end, there will be no grumbling afterwards anyway
 

iamcomming

Active Member
Apr 22, 2024
551
416
Well Jill's path is to my mind the weakest story, but the way I see it the implied explanation is this: Jill has bad experiences with dating. Unless you go the extra miles for her, she doesn't dare to properly trust you. A lot of Jill's stuff can be explained by her relying too much on first impressions and having a bit warped view on bullying. Jill is appalled by violence, but doesn't recognise the dangers of psychological and financial attacks. If you are too aggressive physically, Jill will be a bit too afraid of that aspect of you, but she can't spot Tybalt for what he is.

That's how I make sense of that to myself, but all in all it makes her kinda too demanding for my tastes. Initially I hoped her story would be of a good sheltered girl rebelling with a bad boy and I still hope it turns into that, but the good girl taming the bad boy angle her path seems to be now is not my thing.

But the two big things I can't stand with her are. 1. Not letting the MC take care of Sage when she is sick. It's the most CHICK thing you can do in the entire game and Jill won't have it. 2. The damn banana.

Seriously it would make way more sense for Sage to be too mad at us over that choice, but she is so forgiving.

Sage > Jill
yea, well in my first game i said to Jill, i am not enough good for her and hoping she will say something like it is her choice, but she just accepted that mc not good. so i dont get possible about go with Jill and not for Sage when she sick. only in 2. walktrough. mabye this why i am not so angry about it.
but i forgot the banana, what do you mean?
 

Roger-a-Dale

Member
May 9, 2024
368
527
I don't really see anything to be threatened by. I mean, this guy was saying that me being here and talking shit about DPC in a mean way is a very bad thing yet if only I wasn't "mean" with what I said and I wrote my comments in a genuinely kinder way, then it'd be perfectly okay. He even suggested to actually give DPC "proper advice" as if I'm the consigliere of DrPinkCake or something. That's not really my job, is it? You do see how I might come to the conclusion that the only thing this so-called "argument" is about are his feelings being hurt by what I wrote? And by the way, I never said that I didn't like the game, I only said I didn't like the developer and certain aspects of the game. You're kind of shoving words in my mouth right now. Believe me, I do enjoy the game. Not enough to pay for it, but I do enjoy it as long as I don't take it too seriously. As with any game, it has its own set of flaws and I think pointing those out is perfectly fine, there shouldn't be anything wrong with that. I'm curious as to why you'd want to be on a discussion thread like this if people criticizing the developer or the game isn't something you want to bother yourself with?
You never said you didn't like it? Have you ever praised the parts you do like? If everything you say about the game is a criticism how can you blame people for assuming you are just a hate troll?

And like more than half of your own litany was jumping to conclusions about people giving money to DPC simply for disagreeing with you.

I personally distrust patreon as a whole. Not every dev is a scammer, but the platform is way too easy to use for that. Mostly though the "scams" are just people not understanding the concept of patronage. The money you give there is not a purchase or an investment, it's a donation. It's about giving someone money to support what they are doing. It's something rich people are supposed to do when they don't want to spend their surplus money on taxes.

I absolutely love the story DPC is creating, but I'm not giving him money I need for rent and food.
 
  • Like
Reactions: L1m1tl3ss

Roger-a-Dale

Member
May 9, 2024
368
527
yea, well in my first game i said to Jill, i am not enough good for her and hoping she will say something like it is her choice, but she just accepted that mc not good. so i dont get possible about go with Jill and not for Sage when she sick. only in 2. walktrough. mabye this why i am not so angry about it.
but i forgot the banana, what do you mean?
Jill's Halloween costume on her path.
 

a-lex

Member
Nov 12, 2017
108
81
guys i didnt understand shit

everything is fucking great with jill but my mc chose isabella path and even didnt invite jill to hallowen party we are like 2 strangers now and didnt even made the aftermath of fucking with bella that she saw. i want jill, help me
help me help me help me
 
Last edited:

Roger-a-Dale

Member
May 9, 2024
368
527
guys i didnt understand shit

everything is fucking great with jill but my mc chose isabella path and even didnt invite jill to hallowen party we are like 2 strangers know and didnt even made the aftermath of fucking with bella that she saw. i want jill, help me
help me help me help me
Well the game is telling you that you messed up. Jill wants more from you. Want a list of her demands?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Ekzou

iamcomming

Active Member
Apr 22, 2024
551
416
I understood what you meant. but I think in the end it's better that way. because you're right that an MC DIK should still go to Jill if he cares about her, but then how should he react? because if you don't then give me the opportunity to react differently I'd rather just skip certain appointments.

if you want to from a roleplay point of view imagine that even Mc has realized that Jill is not for him in the end, there will be no grumbling afterwards anyway
yes, but in human relationships need endings, as mc said to Sage after broke up, so i cant understand about it. mc can/must go for Maya and Jojo (Maya also a chick char as Jill, so if he can realizing about girls, than he should do it about Maya too, but there you have a possible try relationship or be just friends) and the last date mc and Jill kissed and were happy -> puff mc not interessed in Jill.:WaitWhat::FacePalm:
i understand your point to wanting the opportunity to skip Jill. i say, you have it by the first date (the tennis), there you can say "i am a nice guy / i am not enough good for you"
i will have 0 problem if Jill reject the mc like Jojo and Maya do. i want it. but i feel insulted and disrespectful about the fact, the mc just overchoice me in a choice based (a)vn and for Sage too.
oh and about the roleplay, about the DnD. there is a rule, the world and everything except the player's chars is ruled by the GM/DM whatever you preferer, the main characters ruled by the players. when mc decide not to go for Jill even the player decide to be on her path, than it is kind of the gm dont let the players to play and forcing
it is a great game, i like the music, the minigames, chars, the story, the humor and so much things, but i just dont like being forced.
 
  • Like
Reactions: felicemastronzo

iamcomming

Active Member
Apr 22, 2024
551
416
guys i didnt understand shit

everything is fucking great with jill but my mc chose isabella path and even didnt invite jill to hallowen party we are like 2 strangers now and didnt even made the aftermath of fucking with bella that she saw. i want jill, help me
help me help me help me
if you go sushi you got Jill ;)
you remember the scene when mc, derek, maya, jojo are study in libary and Jill go to them? if you have there neutral or chick affinity, than she invite the mc to sushi.
 
  • Like
Reactions: a-lex

L1m1tl3ss

Member
Sep 27, 2023
289
572
You never said you didn't like it? Have you ever praised the parts you do like? If everything you say about the game is a criticism how can you blame people for assuming you are just a hate troll?
I did-dent. I'm not blaming anyone for assuming I'm a "hate troll", in fact it seems like an accurate description of me on this forum since you'd be absolutely right to say that the only thing I write about on here is criticism towards the game and the developer. I only responded to you that I don't understand how me taking time out of my day to write "mean comments" is somehow way worse than me spending that same amount of time endlessly praising DrPinkCake. It doesn't matter how I feel about the game, it doesn't matter whether I express how much I like the game or how much I dislike the game, doing either of those things is equally useless if the plan is to reach the developer which it isn't since this is a discussion forum where people engage in different topics and conversations together.
 

a-lex

Member
Nov 12, 2017
108
81
if you go sushi you got Jill ;)
you remember the scene when mc, derek, maya, jojo are study in libary and Jill go to them? if you have there neutral or chick affinity, than she invite the mc to sushi.
sushi with friends?
yeah she invited mc

that is the weird part tho
at no point the story told me i had to choose between jill or isabella. while everything was fine with both of them, jill saw isabella and mc fucking on the table and thats it. we didnt even make the aftermath. i'm playing season 3 now btw, are we gonna make the aftermath and do i lose jill forever?
 

ChipLecsap

Conversation Conqueror
Aug 4, 2019
6,094
22,978
sushi with friends?
yeah she invited mc

that is the weird part tho
at no point the story told me i had to choose between jill or isabella. while everything was fine with both of them, jill saw isabella and mc fucking on the table and thats it. we didnt even make the aftermath. i'm playing season 3 now btw, are we gonna make the aftermath and do i lose jill forever?
huh?
BeingADIK 2024-05-09 19-38-12-77.jpg
You using mods aren't you ? What you describe is highly unlikely, unless you fucked up the game with Mods:whistle:
 

Roger-a-Dale

Member
May 9, 2024
368
527
I did-dent. I'm not blaming anyone for assuming I'm a "hate troll", in fact it seems like an accurate description of me on this forum since you'd be absolutely right to say that the only thing I write about on here is criticism towards the game and the developer. I only responded to you that I don't understand how me taking time out of my day to write "mean comments" is somehow way worse than me spending that same amount of time endlessly praising DrPinkCake. It doesn't matter how I feel about the game, it doesn't matter whether I express how much I like the game or how much I dislike the game, doing either of those things is equally useless if the plan is to reach the developer which it isn't since this is a discussion forum where people engage in different topics and conversations together.
Well, I haven't read the whole thread. It's over 270K posts. I'm never gonna be that bored. But I've never seen anyone "endlessly praising DPC". So even if that would be equal to what you do, why would it matter when no one goes that far? And even if someone actually does, how could two fresh posters possibly be on that level?

And while you own up to being a hate troll, I did describe you as JUST a hate troll. Is there nothing more to you than hate? That's a very sad existence.

"Winners" are people who manage to be happy in life. Spreading hate doesn't make anyone a winner, it just means more people lose.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sikario
4.80 star(s) 1,538 Votes