Sthr ▚ nix

Well-Known Member
Sep 9, 2018
1,457
3,110
If you don't pursue Jill (picnic, sushi, throwing pebbles at her window, etc), she never gets the chance to really see you as anything other than a frat guy who gets in fights and makes trouble all the time. Add the fact that MC never fessed up to the break-in on his own, he does come off very sketchy.
Not only sketchy, but if you don't really try to get to know the MC, he's kinda act like an asshole too. I mean, i think that's the whole point of his fraternity, no? For someone as closed off as Jill, it's kinda makes sense at some degree. But yeah, She's kinda too damsel-y in Season 2. Glad that's not the case anymore in Season 3.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
5,133
17,518
Not only sketchy, but if you don't really try to get to know the MC, he's kinda act like an asshole too. I mean, i think that's the whole point of his fraternity, no? For someone as closed off as Jill, it's kinda makes sense at some degree. But yeah, She's kinda too damsel-y in Season 2. Glad that's not the case anymore in Season 3.
The same thing would've happened with Bella if they didn't sit down to talk all those times in Season 1. When she finds him naked, talking about his childhood in the cafeteria, driving him back to campus the day after their first "date", and so on. Those are all canon, and more importantly, they aren't intertwined with romancing Bella. Off Jill's path, all you really get is the aftermath of your fight with Chad and the tennis date. Everything else is much more casual.
 

DavDR

Engaged Member
Oct 14, 2020
2,025
3,313
It is very noticeable that he fixed Jill for the audience “I am a white knight, and want to save the princess from the tower.” :ROFLMAO: The entire second season of Jill is a Disney fairy tale, she is helpless there and allowed Tybalt to deceive her so naively. One of those moments in the game that sags in writing.
If I wanted to defend DPC (and why would I want too?) I would point out that he was trying to portray Jill as someone who was competent within her comfort zone, but a fish out of water in situations where she was less familiar. But it's a very thin argument. As Felice pointed out some time ago, several of the characters intelligence levels seems to fluctuate in the game, in sync with the needs of the plot.

The only consistently stupid one seems to be Maya.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: godkingxerxes

Radnos Salazar

Active Member
Dec 4, 2023
923
1,588
:HideThePain:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Even without being on her route, she manages to throw her ass so that Mc pays attention :illuminati:
I hope we get atleast 1 3some scene with these beauties either on Jill's route (Preferably) or bellas.....doesn't have to be a throuple relationship just sexual would be amazing
 

Geralt From Rivia

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 15, 2022
6,268
40,013
I know people complain a lot about how Jill won't believe you in Episode 10 about the Hell Week shenanigans unless you're on her path, but honestly it kind of makes sense. Some sense.

If you don't pursue Jill (picnic, sushi, throwing pebbles at her window, etc), she never gets the chance to really see you as anything other than a frat guy who gets in fights and makes trouble all the time. Add the fact that MC never fessed up to the break-in on his own, he does come off very sketchy.

I still love Jill though, I'd never want to hurt her. I've never let her fail the recital, and I never will.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

All of that being said, she's probably 4th favorite MG. Maybe 5th.
This makes sense, I argued this after Ep.10 release. This is not Jill’s stupid behavior, this is her natural doubts about a guy who gets into trouble, who crashed the preps party with Derek, causing a flood, who entered her room without permission!, and possibly rummaged through her personal things.
I hurt her, went the route where I leave her for Bella and Sage (she cried on the bench), and she forgives him. Surprisingly, she copes with this, Jill is truly a holy person, too kind for this world.
Unfortunately, this convinced few; Jill was not liked by this thread from the very beginning of it's existing. She used to be called a raccoon, and when her fans defended her, people wrote "Look, raccoons are attacking", then a goblin, then the thread exploded and made fun of her banana costume. And honestly, I was part of this meme storm and couldn't stand Jill for a while because of her behavior in S2.
So, because of the anti-Jill bias, there are very few of her fans here, only Sthrnix remains active, many of them migrated to off-topic threads and fan Discords.

If I wanted to defend DPC (and why would I want too?) I would point out that he was trying to portray Jill as someone who was competent within her comfort zone, but a fish out of water in situations where she was less familiar. But it's a very thin argument. As Felice pointed out some time ago, several of the characters intelligence levels seems to fluctuate in the game, in sync with the needs of the plot.



The only consistently stupid one seems to be Maya.
It happens when you make changes to the story to show some new idea, but you have no explanation for this idea and it seems forced. Like these changes in Jill's behavior.

Maya did one stupid thing by trusting her father, but I won’t label her “dumb.” Read the damn papers you sign, Maya, and don't do that again. Even if these documents are given to you by your father/husband/brother/girlfriend. People betray, even loved ones.
 
Last edited:

MiltonPowers

Twins Basil! Twins!
Donor
Jul 26, 2023
9,384
18,110
This makes sense, I argued this after Ep.10 release. This is not Jill’s stupid behavior, this is her natural doubts about a guy who gets into trouble, who crashed the preps party with Derek, causing a flood, who entered her room without permission!, and possibly rummaged through her personal things.
I hurt her, went the route where I leave her for Bella and Sage (she cried on the bench), and she forgives him. Surprisingly, she copes with this, Jill is truly a holy person, too kind for this world.
Unfortunately, this convinced few; Jill was not liked by this thread from the very beginning of it's existing. She used to be called a raccoon, and when her fans defended her, people wrote "Look, raccoons are attacking", then a goblin, then the thread exploded and made fun of her banana costume. And honestly, I was part of this meme storm and couldn't stand Jill for a while because of her behavior in S2.
So, because of the anti-Jill bias, there are very few of her fans here, only Sthrnix remains active, many of them migrated to off-topic threads and fan Discords.
Jill fan here. (Well she's in my top 5, Lily #1). Jill is a lovely person, whether you are on her path or not.

And to be completely fair, that Banana costume required ridicule.

I always had a giggle to myself that if you on Jill path, she's a banana, if you're not she's a bumblebee. The hotter costume on the non-path. Almost like DPC (or Jill herself) is saying 'look what you're missing out on'. :ROFLMAO:

screenshot0001.png screenshot0002.png
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
5,133
17,518
This makes sense, I argued this after Ep.10 release. This is not Jill’s stupid behavior, this is her natural doubts about a guy who gets into trouble, who crashed the preps party with Derek, causing a flood, who entered her room without permission!, and possibly rummaged through her personal things.
I hurt her, went the route where I leave her for Bella and Sage (she cried on the bench), and she forgives him. Surprisingly, she copes with this, Jill is truly a holy person, too kind for this world.
Unfortunately, this convinced few; Jill was not liked by this thread from the very beginning of it's existing. She used to be called a raccoon, and when her fans defended her, people wrote "Look, raccoons are attacking", then a goblin, then the thread exploded and made fun of her banana costume. And honestly, I was part of this meme storm and couldn't stand Jill for a while because of her behavior in S2.
So, because of the anti-Jill bias, there are very few of her fans here, only Sthrnix remains active, many of them migrated to off-topic threads and fan Discords.
Speaking very honestly, I don't dislike any of the girls—Madame Rose does not count, she is a waste of time and space. I can find something to appreciate about any of them, I obviously have my favorites, and although I'll indulge in some memery regarding the less popular ones among the community, it's all in good fun. For example, Jill is a cutie, BUT DPC does have her smile weirdly at times, aka "goblin face". I actually found some examples I wanted to bring up in the future, including other characters with said "goblin face".
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
But that’s a whole other discussion. I love Jill and her banana costume, I love Maya and her sandpapery ass, I love Josy and her chrome grill, I love Bella and her insanely voluptuous proportions, I love Sage and her..... well Sage doesn't really have a memeable flaw, none that I know of anyway.

I love them all!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Geralt From Rivia

Geralt From Rivia

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 15, 2022
6,268
40,013
Jill fan here. (Well she's in my top 5, Lily #1). Jill is a lovely person, whether you are on her path or not.

And to be completely fair, that Banana costume required ridicule.

I always had a giggle to myself that if you on Jill path, she's a banana, if you're not she's a bumblebee. The hotter costume on the non-path. Almost like DPC (or Jill herself) is saying 'look what you're missing out on'. :ROFLMAO:

View attachment 3685115 View attachment 3685116
DPC is teasing the players with that moment, at first he pranks the Jill path players, and in second case he shows you a better version of Jill you missed.
I would chose bumblebee Jill all the time, but that not possible :( We even almost not interacting with her during the party and can't choose bumblebee costume for the contest. Seems like Doc cut this content.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MiltonPowers

Riaman

Member
Nov 27, 2020
462
513
This makes sense, I argued this after Ep.10 release. This is not Jill’s stupid behavior, this is her natural doubts about a guy who gets into trouble, who crashed the preps party with Derek, causing a flood, who entered her room without permission!, and possibly rummaged through her personal things.
I hurt her, went the route where I leave her for Bella and Sage (she cried on the bench), and she forgives him. Surprisingly, she copes with this, Jill is truly a holy person, too kind for this world.
Unfortunately, this convinced few; Jill was not liked by this thread from the very beginning of it's existing. She used to be called a raccoon, and when her fans defended her, people wrote "Look, raccoons are attacking", then a goblin, then the thread exploded and made fun of her banana costume. And honestly, I was part of this meme storm and couldn't stand Jill for a while because of her behavior in S2.
So, because of the anti-Jill bias, there are very few of her fans here, only Sthrnix remains active, many of them migrated to off-topic threads and fan Discords.



It happens when you make changes to the story to show some new idea, but you have no explanation for this idea and it seems forced. Like these changes in Jill's behavior.

Maya did one stupid thing by trusting her father, but I won’t label her “dumb.” Read the damn papers you sign, Maya, and don't do that again. Even if these documents are given to you by your father/husband/brother/girlfriend. People betray, even loved ones.
She still acts like that even if you ended with her at a totally positive note. Doesn't matter if you help her through the recital, not mess with Bella. Just do her path but only miss that birthday date without any other red flag she still doesn't believe MC. Off route Jill is very annoying.

Totally different from not believing in MC where you break her heart. Nonetheless my favourite MG but off route very disappointing.

As for Maya her believing in Free tuition scheme and not asking clarification from Sage was very dumb. She still haven't told Sage about the racket Quinn is running, with the hints from MC she should have a rough idea.
 
Last edited:

Riaman

Member
Nov 27, 2020
462
513
Jill fan here. (Well she's in my top 5, Lily #1). Jill is a lovely person, whether you are on her path or not.

And to be completely fair, that Banana costume required ridicule.

I always had a giggle to myself that if you on Jill path, she's a banana, if you're not she's a bumblebee. The hotter costume on the non-path. Almost like DPC (or Jill herself) is saying 'look what you're missing out on'. :ROFLMAO:

View attachment 3685115 View attachment 3685116
You need to thank Bianca for that. Banana Jill is when she has ample time to make choice on her own. It was funny and cute though.

DPC probably only did this to show her childlike innocence and unwrapping joke at the end of party.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MiltonPowers

MiltonPowers

Twins Basil! Twins!
Donor
Jul 26, 2023
9,384
18,110
Speaking very honestly, I don't dislike any of the girls—Madame Rose does not count, she is a waste of time and space. I can find something to appreciate about any of them, I obviously have my favorites, and although I'll indulge in some memery regarding the less popular ones among the community, it's all in good fun. For example, Jill is a cutie, BUT DPC does have her smile weirdly at times, aka "goblin face". I actually found some examples I wanted to bring up in the future, including other characters with said "goblin face".
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
But that’s a whole other discussion. I love Jill and her banana costume, I love Maya and her sandpapery ass, I love Josy and her chrome grill, I love Bella and her insanely voluptuous proportions, I love Sage and her..... well Sage doesn't really have a memeable flaw, none that I know of anyway.

I love them all!
Same, BaDIK is only game where I like every LI and every main side girl. Obviously not Dany, Wendy & that group (but you're not meant to). I've never gone to Madame Rose on any of my playthroughs (just checked the scenes), so I don't really care. I'm pretty meh on Zoey & Sandy, but don't dislike or hate them (just have no interest in them, but gotta admit the Nicole/Sandy threesome was a lot of fun.). I even love some of the Becky moments (like the park & the alcohol incident). But everyone else is enjoyable and fun, on or off their path. I can't think of a single other game where there is no one that annoys me and makes me want to hit the CTRL button. They're all awesome.
 

Geralt From Rivia

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 15, 2022
6,268
40,013
Speaking very honestly, I don't dislike any of the girls—Madame Rose does not count, she is a waste of time and space. I can find something to appreciate about any of them, I obviously have my favorites, and although I'll indulge in some memery regarding the less popular ones among the community, it's all in good fun. For example, Jill is a cutie, BUT DPC does have her smile weirdly at times, aka "goblin face". I actually found some examples I wanted to bring up in the future, including other characters with said "goblin face".
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
But that’s a whole other discussion. I love Jill and her banana costume, I love Maya and her sandpapery ass, I love Josy and her chrome grill, I love Bella and her insanely voluptuous proportions, I love Sage and her..... well Sage doesn't really have a memeable flaw, none that I know of anyway.

I love them all!
Oh, don't tell me:ROFLMAO:
Jills facial expressions it's how the goblin and racoon jokes here was born.
This is the problem of her DAZ model, she can't smile properly and gives out a goblin face. It's a very difficult to change, and I was convinced of this from my own experience, making her smile is a hell of a task.

Chrome teeth is fixable , as for Maya skin too, DPC just don't give a fuck about this. Like a lot of other devs too. Sage has very pale skin.

About dislike list, not to big for me: Josy, Jade, Becky, Madame is count ofc, she's shouldn't exist at all.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Hawke84

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
5,133
17,518
Obviously not Dany, Wendy & that group (but you're not meant to). I've never gone to Madame Rose on any of my playthroughs (just checked the scenes), so I don't really care.
You can't like them even if you tried, unless you also believed in the toxic feminism that these strawwomen are pushing. They are funny though. And Madame Rose would've been literally worthless if it weren't for that stupid interaction in Episode 10, where DPC planted the seed of her possibly becoming a real character in the future.
Oh, don't tell me:ROFLMAO:
Jills facial expressions it's how the goblin and racoon jokes here was born.
This is the problem of her DAZ model, she can't smile properly and gives out a goblin face. It's a very difficult to change, and I was convinced of this from my own experience, making her smile is a hell of a task.

Chrome teeth is fixable , as for Maya skin too, DPC just don't give a fuck about this. Like a lot of other devs too. Sage has very pale skin.

About dislike list, not to big for me: Josy, Jade, Becky, Madame is count ofc, she's shouldn't exist at all.
I dare not mention the pride of DPC, lest I'm also accused of that accursed flaw. But really, idk how he can put these out and not feel embarrassed about the teeth or Maya's ass. And true, Sage is as pale as a vampire, but she's also a ginger so *shrug*
 
  • Like
Reactions: Riaman
Mar 9, 2019
460
1,701
I always saw banana Jill as her not wanting to show off her body when she's committed to Fuckface. When not in a relationship she has no qualms about showing off her body hence the bee costume, but it's well known that she's got this more innocent - not to forget, a little outdated - outlook on romance. The banana fits into her idea of respecting the boundaries of their courtship, which is clearly how Jill views their relationship, while still being able to have fun. That's just my two cents, though.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
5,133
17,518
I always saw banana Jill as her not wanting to show off her body when she's committed to Fuckface. When not in a relationship she has no qualms about showing off her body hence the bee costume, but it's well known that she's got this more innocent - not to forget, a little outdated - outlook on romance. The banana fits into her idea of respecting the boundaries of their courtship, which is clearly how Jill views their relationship, while still being able to have fun. That's just my two cents, though.
I'm not sure she really thinks too much about how flaunts her sexy ass or her big titties. She doesn't cover up when sharing her bed with a stranger, she'll shower next to you on the first date, her boobs fall out when exercising, etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Riaman

iamcomming

Well-Known Member
Apr 22, 2024
1,152
860
Nah. That hairstyle took her from early 20s to mid 40s. I mean granted the original wasn't anything to write home about either. But at least the original didn't age her a couple decades.
with the new hair she is more similar to her mom, but she is sick, so it sad
 
4.80 star(s) 1,573 Votes