Darkwen the Josy lover

Active Member
Dec 14, 2024
779
1,148
Yeah, that being that Maya has way more on her plate and a far deeper story than Josy does. Josy's story is shallower than a rock pool at low tide :LOL:



:ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:

Dude, remove Josy from Maya's equation and she still deals with an abusive, controlling, bigoted father. Remove Maya from Josy's equation and Josy's just a high school prom queen type girl with not much to her besides her looks along with Daddy and family issues. One has it way easier than the other, and let me tell you, it's not Josy. If anything, Josy just exacerbates Maya's issues.

Even though I like the throuple and like both girls, I'm under no illusions as to who they both are and what they're dealing with, particularly Josy. She really isn't her own person at the moment and is more like an accessory to Maya's issues, but not accessory in the fashion sense of the word like she's a sparkly add-on, but more accessory in the crime sense in that she's kinda aiding and abetting this bad situation that's befallen Maya. Doesn't mean I think they should split or anything because I believe Patrick is wrong for doing this, but her whole purpose and that of her relationship seems to be as the focal point of Maya's story and drama which means Josy isn't much of an individual character right now. So in that sense, maybe, she's pivotal but not in a positive way, really.

However, I do believe her and Maya are in love with each other and can be good with each other, they're just in a shitty situation right now that can be improved. Josy, though, really needs to start getting something for herself, finding herself as her own person with her own identity and not just have her whole identity being "Maya's secret girlfriend", which is what it is now. Finding a hobby, finding an individual purpose, finding something that lets her stretch her own wings can be good for her and I want that for her because she needs it so it can improve her own sense of self-worth and identity.

To act like she doesn't need any of that, or that she already has that, or that she's "perfect" as she is and has an amazing individual story already is to be blind to the truth and is the literal definition of looking at someone with rose-tinted love goggles.
I never said Josy doesn't have her problems she does however Josy doesn't bring you down with her unlike Maya. It is very clear throuple or off throuple Josy and Maya prefer MC over the other girl, they once love each other but those days are over. There is zero reason for there relationship not to be better then it is now but there relationship is shit. Maybe it can be save but it will take mc other wise it over.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Riaman

Bootyman92

Member
Jun 25, 2022
267
431
Yeah, that being that Maya has way more on her plate and a far deeper story than Josy does. Josy's story is shallower than a rock pool at low tide :LOL:



:ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:

Dude, remove Josy from Maya's equation and she still deals with an abusive, controlling, bigoted father. Remove Maya from Josy's equation and Josy's just a high school prom queen type girl with not much to her besides her looks along with Daddy and family issues. One has it way easier than the other, and let me tell you, it's not Josy. If anything, Josy just exacerbates Maya's issues.

Even though I like the throuple and like both girls, I'm under no illusions as to who they both are and what they're dealing with, particularly Josy. She really isn't her own person at the moment and is more like an accessory to Maya's issues, but not accessory in the fashion sense of the word like she's a sparkly add-on, but more accessory in the crime sense in that she's kinda aiding and abetting this bad situation that's befallen Maya. Doesn't mean I think they should split or anything because I believe Patrick is wrong for doing this, but her whole purpose and that of her relationship seems to be as the focal point of Maya's story and drama which means Josy isn't much of an individual character right now. So in that sense, maybe, she's pivotal but not in a positive way, really.

However, I do believe her and Maya are in love with each other and can be good with each other, they're just in a shitty situation right now that can be improved. Josy, though, really needs to start getting something for herself, finding herself as her own person with her own identity and not just have her whole identity being "Maya's secret girlfriend", which is what it is now. Finding a hobby, finding an individual purpose, finding something that lets her stretch her own wings can be good for her and I want that for her because she needs it so it can improve her own sense of self-worth and identity.

To act like she doesn't need any of that, or that she already has that, or that she's "perfect" as she is and has an amazing individual story already is to be blind to the truth and is the literal definition of looking at someone with rose-tinted love goggles.
Josy's not perfect, but how much story she has is a subjective view to whoever is playing the game. She's a lot more than just Maya's girlfriend, though. She has her own insecurities, like every other girl, fell for a summer crush whilst being in a relationship, is dealing with the bigotry of her girlfriend's dad and how its affecting their relationship, gets the chance to be with said summer crush and her girlfriend at the same time, takes it hard should they break up (like anyone else would), has to deal with her self-centered stepbrother knowing about her relationship... there's more I could add, but I've made my point.

It's not about who's story is the best, the best thing DPC has done is that he's fleshed out every one of the love interests as people we could see in real life dealing with these situations, and there's no better feeling as a writer than creating a character with depth. I don't see why people have to argue this.
 

Maccabbee

Active Member
Mar 26, 2024
662
993
While Josy and Maya are both imperfect, I still think that as the first two LIs introduced in the game, they were fantastic. They both were extremely sweet, very cute, and a lot of fun. Josy was hot, and the crush vibe was believable. Maya was funny and gorgeous in a believable way. They also both gave fairly clear red flags. Really a great way to intro the game for first time players.
 

Macky009

Engaged Member
Oct 29, 2020
2,592
2,751
First of good afternoon, I was gone for only less than 12 hours and now i'm behind 8 pages. Look's like it will be a long reding for me. Last time I believe someone on what is happening to the thread I'd missed alot of the good stuff that is happening.
I like Josy. When she’s on path of that vacuum cleaner and doesn’t get in the way. :LUL:
sexy-youcanlook.gif
They'd need to complete the beta testing in less than a week for that to happen, and that ain't gonna happen.
We never know but there is still a possiblity.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
7,300
23,540
I thought it would be delayed by the snowball war mini-game.:Kappa:
Real talk, wouldn't that basically be the tennis minigame? You could even have a Dawe face for when you want to get him in the face and balls :HideThePain:

Unless he tries to get fancy and does a whole new thing like with gUndead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KaiserST

Macky009

Engaged Member
Oct 29, 2020
2,592
2,751
That some next level trolling:ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO: Josy is the only reason Maya evens works without Josy no one would like her. If someone doesn't think Josy got a story ok that their right but if then they say Sage has a story then they are a liar because they are the same story and that cannot be argue against
If you compare Sage story and Josy story. Sage has a better character development from ep1 to ep10, most of us thought he is just another Slut. But us the game progress her character and story become more compelling. In Josy's case her story revolves around Maya. From ep01 to ep10 her character development stagnate. In my opinion if you remove Maya in the story, Josy will just be another girl who is in love with mc. There is no story to tell other than the fact that they know each other before college and she is Tommy's step-sister. While if you remove Josy in Maya in the story there will be character development in Maya because the story will progress in helping Maya solving her problem.
 

Ray_D

Forum Fanatic
Nov 13, 2022
4,681
15,245
Real talk, wouldn't that basically be the tennis minigame? You could even have a Dawe face for when you want to get him in the face and balls :HideThePain:

Unless he tries to get fancy and does a whole new thing like with gUndead.
Well I guess there will be a different mini-game depending on if jill invites us to her event. You know snowboarding with jill and snowball wars if we stay on campus. :HideThePain:
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
7,300
23,540
Well I guess there will be a different mini-game depending on if jill invites us to her event. You know snowboarding with jill and snowball wars if we stay on campus. :HideThePain:
Not sure why we'd get one over the other, but I don't want a snowboarding minigame. I want a "make the girls cum as much as possible" minigame :sneaky: In fact, forget the minigame part and make it a nice big XL lewd ;)
 

FalconLover420

Well-Known Member
Nov 23, 2020
1,181
1,227
If you compare Sage story and Josy story. Sage has a better character development from ep1 to ep10, most of us thought he is just another Slut. But us the game progress her character and story become more compelling. In Josy's case her story revolves around Maya. From ep01 to ep10 her character development stagnate. In my opinion if you remove Maya in the story, Josy will just be another girl who is in love with mc. There is no story to tell other than the fact that they know each other before college and she is Tommy's step-sister. While if you remove Josy in Maya in the story there will be character development in Maya because the story will progress in helping Maya solving her problem.

I believe Josy's character is not developed fully like the other love interests. While she may have gotten some screentime, it does revolve around her situation with Maya. Remember right now, she is having this character breakdown on who is she. I believe the winter christmas arc will give her some development on that.

Personally tho, I want more sage, the romance between her and the MC mirrors the non-cuck version of john boy and elena
 
  • Like
Reactions: Macky009

Ray_D

Forum Fanatic
Nov 13, 2022
4,681
15,245
Not sure why we'd get one over the other, but I don't want a snowboarding minigame. I want a "make the girls cum as much as possible" minigame :sneaky: In fact, forget the minigame part and make it a nice big XL lewd ;)
Well, remember the santa chair in the previews of chapter 11, well let's see if we check if the HOT were good girls or bad girls.:sneaky:
dirty hands.gif
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Better Cock Spock
4.70 star(s) 1,635 Votes