Tserriednich'sNen

Engaged Member
Jan 16, 2020
2,253
6,060
A huge stretch? It's a classic storytelling device called the " ", where a character's true nature/lineage is kept from them.

Would it be all that unreasonable to assume that the MC's Mom, who was so hurt after being shunned by her family for running away with his Dad, didn't want her son to know his heritage because she wanted him to have a normal life?

His Dad could have kept this secret from him out of respect for his mother's possible dying wishes and, again, while I am NOT saying that this is the 100%, bona-fide truth, I am saying that it is incredibly easy to see it as a possibility.
"have normal life" of struggling financially and getting bullied due to being poor. Thanks a lot Mom! I'm sure MC will appreciate having such a big secret kept from him.

I personally wouldn't keep a secret like that.
 

Holy Bacchus

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 13, 2018
7,748
19,532
"have normal life" of struggling financially and getting bullied due to being poor. Thanks a lot Mom! I'm sure MC will appreciate having such a big secret kept from him.

I personally wouldn't keep a secret like that.
And that's what would make the MC's Dad a good Dad if this turns out to be the case; honouring his wife's wishes and raising their boy to understand the value of a good, honest living.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nercoz

Mormont

Devoted Member
Nov 30, 2018
11,925
53,085
Can somebody help me?
What version did you download? I had a lot of issues with the 2GB version and my saves were from 4.0 and I couldn't see any phone messages. Ended up donwloading the 8GB version and everything worked just fine after that.
 

BeLikeWater

Member
Apr 27, 2018
103
37
Could someone show where's the little black spot for this line of the walkthrough which happens in Tybalt's room?

"you'll see a little black spot at the bottom right of the books in the bottom left shelf, click that to unlock a special render"
 

jackofshadows

Member
May 24, 2018
290
547
Melanie and Sarah are prime suspects now that Episode 5 has shown they have some sort of agenda on their own. But that mostly just moves the question to what the heck their agenda is, because their scene at the end of Episode 5 still confuses the heck out of me.
Tbh, me too. It just doesn't adds up. I suggest to monocled gentlemens here give one more look into it, attaching few key screens as a reminder.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
He doesn't have to be a B nor a R. Besides I'm sure his father would have told him that his Mom has the same last name as the college he's attending so that debunks that theory.
Precisely. But as far as I'm concerned, when it comes to fan theories, the crazier - the better. This however neigher crazy enough or make any sense.
His Dad could have kept this secret from him out of respect for his mother's possible dying wishes and, again, while I am NOT saying that this is the 100%, bona-fide truth, I am saying that it is incredibly easy to see it as a possibility.
Kept the secret for a mere 18 years and then endorse (or even encourage) submission of documents to the college where, you know, usually hangs out representatives of the family which of course are never ever find it out let alone tell him that. Right... totally make sense.
 

jackofshadows

Member
May 24, 2018
290
547
It's only know to the players, not the MC or Sage, they were too busy doing something else. MC knows about the panty sniffing.
Even if MC have noticed that, how on earth he would have told Jill that?
- B-but how did you know?
- Um... Just heared from some guys who were at the party. By the way, I was totally somewhere else that evening.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EZ8lt

EZ8lt

Engaged Member
Dec 24, 2019
2,494
5,562
Even if MC have noticed that, how on earth he would have told Jill that?
- B-but how did you know?
- Um... Just heared from some guys who were at the party. By the way, I was totally somewhere else that evening.
Exactly. Even the pantie stealing is a no-go, because they committed a break-in and robbery when he saw that.
 

Holy Bacchus

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 13, 2018
7,748
19,532
Kept the secret for a mere 18 years and then endorse (or even encourage) submission of documents to the college where, you know, usually hangs out representatives of the family which of course are never ever find it out let alone tell him that. Right... totally make sense.
The MC's Mom was likely shunned by her family after she ran away to be with Neil, and the feeling was likely mutual. If that were the case, then why would Neil think there's any danger in his son going to the college of his Mom's possible namesake? I don't see Neil having any reason to believe that the MC would be found out, or that the Burgmeisters (if it is them) would even care if they did find out about him.
 

Stark9999999

Member
Dec 4, 2017
115
1,180
"have normal life" of struggling financially and getting bullied due to being poor. Thanks a lot Mom! I'm sure MC will appreciate having such a big secret kept from him.

I personally wouldn't keep a secret like that.
Agree with you but unfortunately there are vibes that this will be the trademark DPC drama that may or may not make complete sense (ie recent Quinn) and you have no control over in episode VI or VII. The game opens with the MC saying he and his dad didn't have much, but he was happy back then (pre letter in this case) and that they had each other. Some of his conversation with Jill, in her bed and especially in the new episode about how bad being cold is when you have no money, give some concern that he will be upset finding out he always should have had money and thus good insulation, working heater/water, etc. The MC may then take it very poorly and have issues with his father. Even more daddy issues than he already has going on with Tommy.
 

Mormont

Devoted Member
Nov 30, 2018
11,925
53,085
Tbh, me too. It just doesn't adds up. I suggest to monocled gentlemens here give one more look into it, attaching few key screens as a reminder.
Some sort of power grab for them? or getting Sage out of the picture. I felt sorry for Sage in this update I've said to others it looks as though Chad is just using her and these so called friends around her are in some way plotting against her. Either way I hope it all fails and Sage has the last laugh on them.
 

resgar

Member
Mar 15, 2020
136
224
Just post here this. To note there is no secrets from dad or mom, just no details other than "important" and "about mom" either, so plenty space for assumptions
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: Esp``
4.80 star(s) 1,553 Votes