Plenty of us want that.
I do however agree that both options should exist, with even possibly a third, where you actively stay friends but help them to stay together, as once again, despite me being flamed for this comment (where funninly enough no one else is for the same opinion, must be a newvie member thing I guess), the MC's reaction is ridiculous as he acts like a husband finding out his wife has been screwing his brother for 10 years.
So there should be an option (and should have been better writing) where you're perfectly happy and accepting of them being together without you and help them when needed. Everyone gets what they want then. That however, also adds three times the amount of work, and as I've also said before, peoples own personal opinions on betrayal and such rubbish is them projecting their own issues onto the characters. We are not playing us, we are playing a pre-definied character within a pre-defined storyline where Maya and Josy are one of the main storyline elements. Deal with that or don't.
The MC does a lot of dumb shit I don't agree with, but such as it is if I want to play the game.