- Aug 27, 2020
- 2,296
- 4,535
Based on the facts we know, she is not possibly the aunt.Not possible. Jill is ~2 years older than MC and MC's mom died giving birth to him, therefore Jill would have been ~2 when her sister died (if the sister was MC's mom). The photo in Jill's room shows her a lot older than that (5+ years old), and she has memories of her sister, so Jill is definitely not MC's aunt.
Things to consider-
1- What if she didn't die during child birth, but was forced by the family to abandon Neil and young MC? Or more likely she died in some way defending the young MC, and Neil came up with the child birth story to not overburden the kid with guilt and grief?
2- Bella being best friends with a girl 14 years her junior is a bit odd. Not impossible, but odd. If Lynette had been her best friend, and told Bella to watch out for her, there would at least be a starting point
3- It has been stated multiple times by various folks that Jill can't be the aunt regardless of the timing based on the stated fact that DPC is not into the incest kink. I would maintain that this could still happen for a number of reasons-
A- DPC loves to throw curve balls into otherwise healthy and happy relationships.
B- To date there has been no sex between Jill and the MC.
C- Bella does not know the parentage of the MC, so she has no reason to speak thus far. A truly twisted future development could have something to do with Lynette being still alive, and having something to do with James and Bella's split.
D- We have 7+ diaries in existence that could shed light on Lynette's life and possible death, though the MC only has one.
So what I am stating is this. It seems unlikely that the MC's aunt is Jill. I do not think anything absolutely forbids that, including the picture and DPC stating that he is not into incest. He IS into throwing real crazy stuff into a story to bollocks it all up, and since we have not had sex with Jill, incest has not occurred. Is it emotional incest if true? Yes. Is it the illegal kink kind of incest no.
So while we believe at the moment that Jill is not the MC's aunt, I don't think it has been retired from all possibilities. DPC has killed off MAIN MAIN MAIN Love Interests before, for no greater reason than to cause a broken heart for the sake of the story. I would not put it past him to do the same here, but without killing Jill, just making her completely unavailable.