If you didn't go down the "man whore" path (except he didn't get paid, so basically just "slut" path), you'd probably end up with Maya and Josey. They only let you down if you're not CHICK enough or if you never had sex with Josy and you never made out with Maya. And if you're a DIK, you should be claiming all the territory that comes with it.
Just to clarify, the sheepish bit was at the party (not back at the dorm room), when she comes up to ask the mc for help, you can see she's embarrassed about what's transpired, but she'd still rather make out with the MC than any of the other guys she doesn't know.
Anyway, enjoy your thanksgiving, and that goes for all your guys and gals celebrating today.