In my mind because of what's going on with Maya's dad, the girls will likely decide Josy has to go somewhere else, so she'll move into the HOTs. That separation will likely open up solo routes with the girls and drive a wedge between them. MC will still have options to help Maya though I would imagine if the player wants to (hope nothing is forced).
I'm inclined to agree.
I think the most likely resolution to the cliffhanger with Maya's father is that the MC and Maya will somehow manage to conceal Josy from him, and bluff that Maya has been obeying his demands. This will allow us to meet her father and firmly establish his threat to their relationship without having to resolve the matter once and for all immediately.
That in turn will justify Josy moving into the HOTs without Maya, which will start straining their relationship without immediate risk of destroying it. It will also conveniently allow the MC to interact with them individually, which could eventually result in solo paths for each girl.
The other plausible outcomes seem to other subplots until the crisis is resolved) or else her dad has to back off his ultimatum (which badly undercuts his threat going forward). If he leaves before the trio arrives, it makes the cliffhanger a very unsatisfying anti-climax and still forces the MC to spend a bunch of time strategizing with the girls. If he falls for the old 'fake boyfriend trick' it plays out as a less plausible version of one of the previous options.
If I asked your number 1 girl right now who would you say and why ? GO
Maya. I find her extremely sympathetic and (skin texture aside) very attractive. Plus she's a ton of fun to be around when she's not wracked with anxiety, so I would very much like to help her move beyond that and grow into the woman she wants to be.
The runners up would be Josy, then Sage (assuming we can romance her without being her fuck buddy), and finally Jill. (For the record, Jill was narrowly in second place before the blackmail subplot sucker punched her.)