VN Ren'Py Being a DIK [v0.10.1] [DrPinkCake]

[Holy Bacchus]

Josy is portrayed as a gregarious sort yes but I don't think she falls in love with everyone. She is just more daring than Maya. DPC is really pushing the theme of Jill and Josy being close "friends." He is pushing it much more than is normal. Ok, we get it, they are friends, why keep reminding us at every turn and then specifically showing us that MC is conflicted about it? There has to be a greater point to of all of this. As soon as I saw Jill with Josy on first playthrough, I knew I was going to get cucked, but now I think it is more of an emotional connection when they both need it most (although I'm certainly not ruling out some scissoring).

Ultimately, I think if Maya and Josy do separate, it will be brief and they will reunite. I don't think Jill-Josy will be a forever thing. Just enough to cause some story conflict.

I don't see how he's really pushing anything with regards to a Jill/Josy relationship. If anything what he's doing is building an actual friendship between these 2 in order to fuel potential rivarly/jealousy/guilt between them and adding to the drama of dating/pursuing multiple girls. Or maybe it's to make the eventual choice easier if these girls get to know each other so well that they might even encourage the MC to pursue the other if they feel like it's best for him.

For example, if the relationship with Jill is not the best (i.e. not at max RP, certain event flags not triggered, etc) but it's better with Josy (and potentially Maya too), then maybe Jill will end it citing him clearly being more interested in Josy and she'll tell him to be with her, even if it tears her up to do it, because she at least likes Josy and knows they'll be good together, and vice-versa with Josy.

I think Josy only fell for the MC because she was on the rocks with Maya at the time. Once she got back with Maya she was happy.

The "rebound" angle may be how it started, but I think she does genuinely like him and would love nothing more than all 3 of them being together. So whilst she is happy to have Maya back, she's also also happy to have the MC on the throuple path and the unhappiness at not having him on the non-throuple path is probably a factor that will lead to a rift between M&J.

With all these theories i feel like it's impossible for none of them to be true, we just don't know which ones.

Not dalli_x's, that's for damn sure.

 

[Anthony11553]

I want someone to make an alternate timeline where every single theory becomes true.

 

[AchedCroissant]

Do we really need another lesbian virgin?

Yes

 

[Deleted member 6239]

I want someone to make an alternate timeline where every single theory becomes true.

Even the one where Derek gets it on with Neil?

 

[rj677]

I don't know. I agree Sage doesn't seem especially interested in girls, and I don't see her getting into any sort of long-term poly situation. But I could see Sage being up for a light foursome where the three girls fool around with the MC a bit. Probably not to the point he has sex with all three, but somewhere close. Sage does claim to have a kinky side and I think she'd enjoy teasing the MC a bit.

Even then, I don't see her "kinky" side applying to stuff involving other girls or them doing things with the guy she's with/crushing on. We've got Maya, Josy, Quinn, Riona, Nicole, Sandy, and possibly Camila, Lily, Sarah, Melanie, Jade, and Cathy to satisfy the girl/girl itches and don't really need all of them to have a sapphic side. (And yes, I say this still fully believing in the Bella/Jill theory, but that just makes me feel more that it would be best that Sage doesn't have a sapphic side.)

I think that at this point of the story (Ending of Ep6) Sage, in my opinion, is in between both of your opinions stictly because shes now starting to contemplate the MC as "Possible LI" and not just a "Fuck Buddy" like she did in the beginning of their arrangement.

She does have a kinky and exploring side that we got to see through the episodes like the Control or Domination choice, the asshole tease that lead us to believe that she would be down to do some Anal when the place is more appropriate ( The DIK library hopefully ) and the Forbidden/Sneaking around. Thats the side that would accept a threesome or foursome but only with girls she likes and trusts to explore that lesbian side and to experience group sex (For Example Quinn, because she already knows and caught them having fun and because Sage throws the MC over to her in Ep4).

However, the Sage that is now Single and contemplating the MC as a "Possible LI" probably doesnt want to "share her food" and if she did that would be a good way DPC could build Sages jealousy and maybe makes her want to take the relationship to the next step .

But seeing as the game is FAR from finishing, I think we will have a lot more of the Fuck Buddy Jealous Building Sage , than the Relationship Dating in Love Sage

In other words, the transition between "Its just Sex and People put the pussy in some unnecessary pedestal" to "Sex must be with someone youre Dating or Love" is a LONG WAY from happening

 

[Anthony11553]

Even the one where Derek gets it on with Neil?

The hardest choices require the strongest wills

 

[godkingxerxes]

Yes

Jill is more interesting if she goes off with Tybalt instead of Josy.

At least then she won't be a virgin anymore.

 

[Kellermann]

So what you're saying is... the big twist for Bella is NOT James, but some Carrie type shit.

Nice, wholesome fun.

Had to internet search this. The movie yes? I haven't watched it, but anything is possible I guess.

 

[godkingxerxes]

Even the one where Derek gets it on with Neil?

That's not a theory though, that's a promise from Derek.

It can happen during a parents visiting day, Derek and Neil head to the closet, and MC takes Derek's mother to the library.

 

[Anthony11553]

Tybalt and Tommy are complete chads, mark my works this will be a commonly expected idea in 2022

 

[Deleted member 2528490]

Had to internet search this. The movie yes? I haven't watched it, but anything is possible I guess.

Movie, novel, either work. Its a bloodbath either way.

 

[Gladheim]

So... whats new?

 

[Anthony11553]

I bet no one has brought up the idea that Magmar will shoot up in the school and cause some deaths/injuries

 

[shazba]

Maya & Josy are going to be rocky again, you can already see the cracks and clearly Josy is at least temporarily going to the HOTs (ref pool photo) while Maya likely isn't. And once Dad Maya finds them together, shit is really going to blow up. I'll bet the pool shot happens after Dad finds them and a big argument ensues. If you aren't in a relationship with them, then I think Josy is going to Jill for comfort. And again, why would DPC harp on the Jill Josy friendship so incessantly if there wasn't more to it? It's more than just awkwardness over MC sleeping with Josy.

I kinda feel the Jill/Josy friendship was stressed numerous times to make it OK that Jill joined the Scooby Gang. Now on pain of excommunication: I don't want a Josy/Jill threesome. I mean I'd live with it if it happened, but it's not something I'm hoping for.

The "rebound" angle may be how it started, but I think she does genuinely like him and would love nothing more than all 3 of them being together. So whilst she is happy to have Maya back, she's also also happy to have the MC on the throuple path and the unhappiness at not having him on the non-throuple path is probably a factor that will lead to a rift between M&J.

I agree the relationship blossomed and she now has strong feelings for the MC, whether they ended up together at this point or not, but what I mean is she wouldn't have started something like that in the first place if the relationship with Maya wasn't going down hill.

Had to internet search this. The movie yes? I haven't watched it, but anything is possible I guess.

You had to search Carrie? Like seriously WTF, they even made a remake with Chloë Grace Moretz in case some people didn't know this classic! For the uninitiated, search for Carrie opening sequence... now that's how you grab your audiences attention!

 

[Kellermann]

So... whats new

Well apparently Jill is now gay and she and Josy are running away together. So basically just the usual thread awesomeness.

 

[AchedCroissant]

Jill is more interesting if she goes off with Tybalt instead of Josy.

At least then she won't be a virgin anymore.

I disagree because both a woman with a man can be interesting but a woman with a woman can also be

If you have time or if you are interested in reading something, I recommend you read this Korean manwha, it is Yuri GirlxGirl and you will know why you do not always need a penis to make things interesting

 

[Deleted member 6239]

So... whats new?

We are running out of theories to discuss. People are losing their minds... So I guess same old?

 

[godkingxerxes]

I bet no one has brought up the idea that Magmar will shoot up in the school and cause some deaths/injuries

Somebody shooting the school, been there done that.

But Magnar, nah, dude is legit, he's the one true president, and also hottest girl in the school is his girlfriend. He's a winner.

 

[Hesteros]

After doing a replay for the first time in awhile, I really have to say Sage is growing on me. I've actually been enjoying her character arc and both her major sex scenes are legitimately great.

I'm interested in her issues with her family. She comes from a rich family but doesn't act like one, even more so than Jill. We knew from the start that Jill is wealthy but only in Ep 5 we learnt about Sage. Quinn suggested that she asked her family for money like Rusty but then she got pissed off saying "that's a line that won't be crossed". She did mention that her parents neglected her emotionally but I can't help but think there's more.

Chad is also hiding a big secret and it's not a simple infidelity. There are hints that the secret is related to his sexuality but so far no hard evidence. Whatever his secret might be, it's clear that Sarah and Melanie knew about it. I wonder what would happen if Sage found out that the two have been hiding it from her.

There's two reasons that Sage had a huge fight with Chad; the infidelity and his emotional (as well as sexual) neglect. She have no shoulders to cry on; her parents would brush it off, and she only talked about HOT stuff with her "sisters". MC could be the first person to give her what she had been denied her whole life.

 

[Anthony11553]

you mean the sexathon ? real cool down indeed! the only bad part at it is if you go with Josy and ask her where is the carpet (where she will get crabs from sleeping in the same room as Arieth) you do not get a Cathy BJ, and everyone wants a teacher BJ!

Cooldown in terms of story progression obviously