Yes Maya did first tell the mc she had a boyfriend, but she rescinded it later saying she only said that to discourage other guys, and eventually he finds out she's a lesbian. She never lets him know she's actually in a relationship until it's too late, then uses the lame excuse that she tried to tell him.
I want to take this comment as an oportunity to explain my point of view on this issue. Maya sayd she didnt had a boyfriend and that was a lie... yet i dont find it a terrible lie at all, almoast an insignificant problem.
First: in the same way that Josy cheat the main victim is Maya, the main victim of Maya lie is not MC but Josy, couse the goal of that lie is to give MC green light to advance on her. If i found that my girlfriend is saying that she is not in a relationship then i will asume she wants to cheat on me and i will be mad. If i find that a girl who is flirting with me says she is not in a relationship, when she is, then i will asume she is interesed in me. You can hardly feel the victim there. As long as the MC is the proyection of the reader into the story, there is no really point for the player (all of us, including Maya haters) to be angry with her. The same way we dont get really angry against Jade cheating on Burke or Derek cheating on Ashley. And yet the own Josy needed 5 minutes to forgive Maya, the MC needed a couple days and Maya haters are complaining about this issue after 1 year(?).
Second: couse at the end of the day Maya cheats on Josy with the MC for one reason: to give the player a sex scene with her. It's mostly ment to give sexual gratification to the player!, and i find that a extremely justifible reason to lie. This is what blows my mind the most about Maya haters.
Now, in an effort to make some sense on Maya haters i will asume this: As long as Maya lies to the MC to have sex with the MC wich efectively happens...the only way for the player to feel somehow cheated is if you had not a purely sexual interest but rather romantic feelings for Maya. If you were looking for sex, congrats she made it possible, if you were looking for love, well the fact that she had a relationship could be a problem. It kind of remind me more about womans complaining about man cheating on her wifes that any complain i ever heard of any man, but lets asume is ok to avoid sexism. Then:
Third: This is a porn game.
Fourth: The MC still gets not one romantic relationship but a trouple romantic relationship. He gets everything. As long as at the end the MC gets the relationship, now we can conclude that Maya wasnt "playing with him", she was serious about this issue. She just was confused about her own feelings. And even if she was confused, the resolution is still a happy one. So how can anyone have a complain about this.
I understand anyone who doesnt like Maya. It's called bad taste and there is nothing wrong with that. But i don't understand how anyone can complain about how she treated the MC.