- Aug 4, 2020
- 3,506
- 19,688
Ok, but Jill explicitly relays that "...sprinkler system started and ruined things on the first floor." By omission, the second floor was therefore untouched. So the mc just got lucky.It's just an idea since Jill's piano is perfectly fine after the sprinklers are activated, and it's not stated whether or not the sprinklers on the second floor were activated. Thus, there are assumptions that Sage might've covered the piano with a cloth to prevent it from being exposed to the water as she's from a wealthy family and understands how to properly maintain pianos. MC didn't even have a single thought regarding Jill's piano, after all he was caught in the chaos and didn't really think about Jill at the time either, evidenced by his "oh shit!" thought when Jill mentioned her piano at Bella's.
IMO it's a perfectly reasonable theory, since we don't really know if the sprinklers on the second floor were activated, so all we can do is assume, and given the chronology of events, the idea seems coherent and logical.