The bit about the replays not feeling like "the first time", I agree 100%.
Playing this game for the first time (for me it was episodes 1 to 5 straight) was a great experience.
Replaying it again is still fun, but considering that we've dissected everything to atomic proportions, it's rare to find any new nuggets of gold to make the subsequent playthrough special (until we reach the new content of course).
But I don't get the bit about "the story of BADIK seems to me to be hostage to the distribution of the twists and turns".
Every story is hostage to itself. No story is complete until it is complete. We don't want the final scene, the one that wraps everything up, to be presented midway through the story.
You could ask for each episode to be encapsulated within itself and each new story arc begins and ends before the next episode comes out (given the extensive wait between episodes, that isn't an unreasonable request), but then what would there be to look forward to in the next episode?
I reckon it's the
long list of questions that we have, and situations awaiting resolution, that keep us here chatting away all the time.
That said, each person has their saturation point, the point where you can't wait any longer for one issue or another to be resolved, and it could begin to detract from the enjoyment of the game.
For me, I'd like to see Maya's issues with her dad resolved soon, but I don't enjoy the game any less because of it.
Considering we all probably have very little control over the final outcomes of this game (other than who the mc fucks and who he'll possible end up with), so when it comes to the drama, just sit back and enjoy the ride.