Well you don't really have to restart for different path. Its depend on what you want to achieve.?!
With a
Neutral playthrough, you can pretty much chase all of the Main Girl and only make the final decision at the end of episode 8.
whether if its makes sense or not is a different story. For Me it does not felt right to choose Jill over Josy, after everything I did with Josy.
The problem is the affinity system, that is a little bit messing the thing if you also aim for a specific affinity. apparently even if you end up with only one Chick slice, you still end up as neutral
View attachment 1581731