I wouldn't call him incorrect, that would be too extreme. Arguing that your interpretation is not an interpretation, and the scene in question is not up for interpretation is moronic at best, trolling at worst. You even accused him of lying because you literally did not like his interpretation dude, chill. This isn't healthy.
You know what Dik and Chick are? They are content! And true fans do not question which one is better or worse, we don't need to... We just consume them like bread and wine at this point!