Sorry to un-derail the Chad conspiracy...
That's an interesting point. Possibly far fetched, but perhaps some of this "evidence" wasn't meant for Sage, it was meant for the Jocks. Perhaps Chad is pretending to be on a call with Sage (the Jocks think he is) to keep up the charade of being in a hetero relationship with Sage. It backfired though, because Sage saw it as something else. That's why he looked so shocked when Sage called him out for cheating during their breakup, because he really wasn't cheating with anyone. He obviously wasn't happy with Sage, he just used her to disguise his homosexuality. All that said, it did seem like he really was interacting with someone on the other end of the call, even pausing because he heard something and then telling them it was no one.
But some serious questions about Chad (
my own answers are in red):
- Why was he with Sage for three years when he didn't even look interested in being with her way back before the DIKs were formed? Because Chad is gay.
- Sage complains that he needs to start getting more physical with her. Why has he never been physical with her from the get go but he's all about putting fingers in someone else on the call? Because he is gay.
- Why did Troy leave the Jocks? Because he is gay.
- How was Mel talking to Chad when she was on the treadmill in earshot of others? She wasn't, it's a ruse that Chad puts on to convince other's he's not gay (I'm thinking this is far fetched, but if you're gonna go with a conspiracy theory, why not go all in).
- Why would Chad be adamant that he is not cheating on Sage when she's accusing him of cheating during their breakup? They are breaking up, what is she gonna do if he admits to cheating, break up with him? He wasn't cheating. He probably wants to be with someone else but isn't actually cheating.
- Why is the story so specific about Chad being in the eastern wing after letting you know that was the wing you were staying in. Apart from specific locations like, "Dik's mansion", "HOTs house", "Prep's mansion", "Pink Rose", "Library", there aren't a lot of specific locations, but the eastern wing is specified. Is it a clue or just useless information? Because Chad and Troy are together.
- Where is Troy sneaking out to at night? To see Chad. Could totally be drug related too.
- Why does Troy want you out of the dorm so badly. Because he is gay.
- Why do the Jocks comment that they've never seen Chad seem so happy? They literally say, " I saw him yesterday, he seemed happy. It was weird. Never saw him as a positive guy". So Chad never seemed happy/positive around them, like ever? Why was that, and why is he happy now? Because he is gay and he doesn't have to pretend that he is straight when around them all the time anymore.
- What was the blackmail and why was it so bad that it brought Chad to tears in front of the MC? Something gay.
- As per Sage's complaints, why does Chad pay attention to Sage when others are around but not when they are alone? Because he's trying to convince people he is gay.
- Why does Chad have perfumed, lady's undergarments on his person? I'd say "Because he is gay", but that just comes across ignorant...
- We have a lesbian couple, where is the gay couple to balance it out? Chad and Troy, solved.
Now sure, 100% all of this is circumstantial and a lot of it is stretching things, but seriously, there's a lot. Definitely a lot more there pointing to the gay conspiracy than there is pointing towards any other scenario.
And the Mel theory? Seriously, who would break up with someone as hot, beautiful and now we find out rather intelligent (not to mention she's the president of the HOTs), like I was saying, who would break up with this heavenly creature to go with Mel. A girl who sleeps around (remember Sage only started it as revenge for Chad, plus the mc is totally irresistible, just ask every other girl in the game, even lesbians can't resist him - OK he's struggling with the geekosphere a bit), and doesn't seem all that interesting...
No, Chad is gay!
I wonder if there will be a branch where the mc is bi...