You forgot the best part of all...Which I accept the first time but making repeated mistakes and not learning or adapting while still walking towards the big bad everyone else is terrified of isn't a good look on them. When the first big incident happens they even mention having a sentry duty at night then proceed to not have one nor mention it ever again.
Especially when Hannah and Skylar seem to have picked theirs up pretty quickly meanwhile their fighter can't fight, their mage can barely do magic, the girl we know can sense magic and has done so a few time already walks straight into the middle of a fairy portal, their cleric has done 1 solitary thing and that's heal an arm.
Yet not a single one of them has said "you know what, we kinda suck at this, maybe we should train a bit before we give the most powerful being in the realm a bunch of easy kills and hand over the very thing she needs"....
They suck because they are new and have one more release to =
-Free themselves
-Get Gud
-Reach their destination
-Survive
-Have an ending that makes sense if you have brain cells
I'll be the first to admit that I was roped in by early effort and potential. I read into what was suggested and hinted at. Only to learn it was a lot of sizzle with no steak.