there is a total of 4 failed big brother games that tailored only max story. maybe you want this game to be 5th failed game? this dev needs to continue with it's 3 path arc or risk bait and switching his patreons. mark my words if this goes MAX only will flop.
So you say a game called big brother can only be successful with a cretain side character ... ok. That argument does not really convince me, but you are entitled to your opinion.
I think they failed because the writing was crap. It was nothing more than a collection of sex scenes after a while (with or without Eric, no matter) without anything supporting it. Those who want that, won't be happy with
any game, a VN would be better suited for them.
Little Sister had some nice ideas, it would actually make a fine VN, but the gameplay is SO bad, that 90% of the time it's just frustrating, so you can't enjoy the scenes you actually manage to find.
Alexey is no genius when it comes to writing or character development, Ann is just as bad as she always was (I still have hope that he will do something about that). But he has the right spirit. What I like here is that he puts a lot more focus on a rather natural progression than the others before him. Here we have a much slower approach and also a
lot more variations for the single situations, Alexey succeeds at making each one count. Spider prank at the shower?
Original: 3 pics, the end. BBAS: be mean, be nice, get slapped, get hugged, get slapped for hugging the wrong body part. And I am sure I missed a few variations.
Ann so far was just a side character being banged by a cretin. I am looking forward mostly of what he makes of Alice, his attempt here is by far better than anything in the other games. And I
do hope he will change Ann drastically.
So far the majority is happy without Eric, so there's that. Yes, there are some rather loud complaining Eric lovers around, but not nearly as many as those who find him annoying. But the dev already said that on friendship path there will be more Eric, so the few that are here for that guy get what they want as well. But in most plots Eric plays no role at all, not in the past, not now and not in the future.
What the dev "needs" to do is to do his own thing, listening to whiners from either faction as little as possible.