Spiders, spiders and even more spiders are your friend.
Keep both Lisa and Alice mood and Max authority over them at max at all times.
Punish later will be lost for 1 week if you forget to punish one of the girls so just wait a week and it will come back.
Go around and talk to everyone and see if new convo happens.
Just keep playing and things will change.
Unfortunately, now after several MONTHS, nothing new has happened.
Yes, I've gotten the punish option back (thank you).
I do spiders on all possible nights with HJ as only result.
I talk to everyone each day.
Always max mood on everyone at all times.
I punish Alice every day, and try out all different times to do it (8,9,10,11) with or without Kate. All days. No new scenes. I get to fuck Alice both privately and with kate (except Fridays at 8 before club, which I only get to grope).
Here's exact breakdown of what I do every day:
I do HJ with mom in shower at 6am, then (topless) yoga.
I do BJ with Lisa in bathroom at 7am.
I do Massage with HJ with mom right after breakfast.
Do all chores. Setup Alice. Get new spider. Maxes everyones mood if dropped.
In the evening I vary between Anal in the kitchen with Lisa, Wacthing TV, Blowjob with Alice, Punishment, Blog repetetive scenes.
Always do all bathroom scenes with Mom and Lisa at 8 and 10.
When Kate is present I do the punishment with her (same scene every time).
When Kate isn't present I do the spider (except Friday).
I also do mom HJ in bed occationally. As well as play with Lisa if I got nothing better to do.
No new dialogue or progress in any of the active quests: Arachnophobia, Blog, New Job and Cunning Plan.
Last dialogue was with Kira about checking around for some Potency pills.
Pleeeeease help me, how do I "break the cycle".