- Jan 29, 2023
- 78
- 41
Is there anyone with full save guy old save does not work and y dont to do it all over again thanks
Does that lower the quality of the scenes? Am I phoning in the vanilla side of the game just to get the ntr?So the whole point of including the vanilla side of the game is to make a ntr game?
My concern for you as a dev and game is that you are trying to please everyone and it will please no one, looking at this thread if you just read the comments it looks like a game that is building just for the ntr. I do not deny you have a great passion for the game and writing far from it, i just look and think you have turned away the vanilla players for a game that was focused on that, then the ntr was going added has to be a dlc, but reading comments here and on itch you have changed that so you are adding it earlier in development, and looking at the reply's here you seem more stoked about the ntr, which is also adding to the uninterest and lack of involvement from vanilla players, which i why i said about identity crisis.Does that lower the quality of the scenes? Am I phoning in the vanilla side of the game just to get the ntr?
'Cause the last time I checked, I cared about the scenes and the dialogue I've written.
That's the thing I don't get about pure-vanilla people in regards to my game, you know that there's going to be NTR, so yeah in a sense, the girls that you're trying to win over may get content that you absolutely despite. but because the sole existance of NTR in the future, then that just diminishes all the content of the vanilla side? Furthermore, So far the only content in the game is vanilla, and it's going to be like that for several patches.
I just don't know how to deal with the whole pure-vanilla mindset, if I say, "no, vanilla peeps are my focus" how does that change anything? Like people said in pages before, even if that's the answer, I think, rightfully so, many people will still have their doubts and overall refuse to support a dev that's going to add NTR in the future, so I'm screwed in that regard.
And if I say the contrary; then I'm just using vanilla peeps while I secretly desire to make a NTR game? Like I can't win against that, and just trying to find the middle ground with that tribe is not possible. At the end of the day, I'm still working on content that they enjoy or want (Vanilla), content that I also enjoy making regardless of the label, so again, which one is it going to be? I'm just finding me in a dammed if I do, dammed if I don't situation constantly.
If you have an answer to that, I would love to hear it, but if you don't, then I think this game, or me as dev, just might not be for you.
Heck, I think you could also see it as me wanting to create a NTR game and still gettting a hopefully pretty good vanilla harem as a by-product, you don't see the NTR folks geting upset because the vanilla folks got taken care of, do you?
For the combat, to make things more streamlined, what you could do is have the 3 different types of goblins actually appear on the map, instead of having just one generic model. That way, you can select the right counter girl without having to first engage the goblin to see what it is.What I gotten from the replies is that:
- I'll be adding a way to skip the intro in the future,
- I don't know if its possible to reduce the map, I actually don't feel like that is a big issue, what I can do is make it so you can teleport around for fast travel
If you can give me more info on how that error appeared I could fix it soon hopefully.
In regards to the combat, I might end up finding a way to simplify aspects of it, it's a nice idea and I really like the system, but it's an idea that worked a hell of a lot better in paper.
and to echo that feeling, having both sides of NTR and Vanilla is something that also seemed good in paper but man, I couldn't be any more wrong if I tried, had I know what I know now, I would have absolutely picked a side, in my eyes, I think to have NTR there needs to be an element of a relationship, so my plan was to have them develop a relationship with the MC, and I figured if you're going to have that, might as well have the option to romance them outright (ergo vanilla, and if you're going to be doing vanilla, might as well make it good if it's going to be there), plus if it's the god-given right of the MC to marry them I feel that could make it spicier (?) to have the option of guys trying to corrupt and steal away what is yours.
Essentially I used to think that in order to have a good NTR game, you needed the bases of a good-to-great vanilla lovey-dovey romance, and that still might be true, but I went the wrong route in how to accomplish that, the game is definitely in a weird no-mans-land lacking a niche that unites several concepts together, I'm trying to fix it as I go along, but yeah, this was quite possible the dumbest road I could have taken but hey, you live and learn.
The silver linning is that reading some of the suggestions on how to approach the NTR in the future seem really good, so when I eventually get there, I do have a lot of ideas on how to go about creating that path.
At the moment I still think that the best course of action is to continue to focus on developing characters to establish that relationship, don't get me wrong, I actually enjoy writting and creating vanilla relationships that end up in marriage and happy ever after, I'm not in any personal hurry to start adding NTR, However, the NTR side of the people I have interacted with have been surprisingly more civilized and fair, so I do want to give them what they want in return.
I just gotta hold on for several updates while I fix the mess I created for myself.
There is an extremely vocal population here that subscribes to the "Squeaky wheels get the most oil" mentality. This is because SEVERAL games on this platform have completely flip flopped from Pure Vanilla to Semi Vanilla/NTR to Pure NTR and every other direction in between because of dogpiling and the hopes that it will improve funding.At the moment I still think that the best course of action is to continue to focus on developing characters to establish that relationship, don't get me wrong, I actually enjoy writting and creating vanilla relationships that end up in marriage and happy ever after, I'm not in any personal hurry to start adding NTR, However, the NTR side of the people I have interacted with have been surprisingly more civilized and fair, so I do want to give them what they want in return.
I just gotta hold on for several updates while I fix the mess I created for myself.
As a Vanilla fan, I personally do not care at all if NTR is present in games when it is a fail state caused by a player's lack of action. The only exceptions to that rule are the following.That's the thing I don't get about pure-vanilla people in regards to my game, you know that there's going to be NTR, so yeah in a sense, the girls that you're trying to win over may get content that you absolutely despite. but because the sole existence of NTR in the future, then that just diminishes all the content of the vanilla side? Furthermore, So far the only content in the game is vanilla, and it's going to be like that for several patches.
If you have an answer to that, I would love to hear it, but if you don't, then I think this game, or me as dev, just might not be for you.
I agree with most, i think a big part of vanilla fans were supportive of the idea of a dlc at the end, yeah there was some moaning, but the dev has changed stance on it, so is adding it earlier, so in a way it is invoking the feelings like all the other devs that have flipped flopped, (it has happened to me 3 times now supporting a dev/game, one was after 3 years of support). Also what usually happens is that the mc has to grind and grind to get anywhere in the game to prevent the ntr from happening and it sucks the enjoyment out of a game that otherwise has a good story. But that's just my opinion.There is an extremely vocal population here that subscribes to the "Squeaky wheels get the most oil" mentality. This is because SEVERAL games on this platform have completely flip flopped from Pure Vanilla to Semi Vanilla/NTR to Pure NTR and every other direction in between because of dogpiling and the hopes that it will improve funding.
While I think you did the logical thing addressing the split head on and describing exactly how it would be implemented, the outrage you're seeing is people hoping you will bend to their tastes. Sadly it's a poor behavior that has been incentivized. That being said, this behavior is just as visible on both sides of the "divide". If you don't believe me, there are tons of complaints in this particular thread you can read through. https://f95zone.to/threads/arrival-of-the-goddess-v1-02-ntrman.217630/
I think you're catching most of it from Vanilla fans at the moment because you're starting with Vanilla content, but it could also be because of another trend I noticed. Some developers who attempt to introduce NTR do so in a way that "corrupts" the underlying narrative. They will use tactics like calling it avoidable when it isn't, or simply saying it's avoidable when in reality that just means the player doesn't have to see it but it still happens for story purposes. This has created a profound sense of distrust that ultimately results in people not accepting ANY form of "cucking".
As a Vanilla fan, I personally do not care at all if NTR is present in games when it is a fail state caused by a player's lack of action. The only exceptions to that rule are the following.
1) There is so little vanilla content that there is no reason to play the game. It feels like a waste of time and it makes playing the game feel like you're trying to make the experience something it was never meant to be. This is a common outcome for games because development takes a lot of time, and splitting routes like this multiplies that exponentially. As Golzd mentioned, you can easily end up in a situation where you try to please everyone and end up pleasing no one.
2) The Heroines personality/demeanor shifts drastically either during the NTR or during gameplay despite avoiding the NTR. The former usually takes the form of them folding like a plastic chair during sex and ultimately makes it feel like they don't care about the MC at all. It also just feels like lazy writing. The latter refers to the earlier point I mentioned of the NTR/corruption happening behind the scenes despite avoiding it.
3) The "avoidable" fail state isn't actually avoidable. The NTRman game I linked had a decent example of this but I think it's been fixed. Basically NTR was avoidable if you won the minigames but one of them was so extremely difficult that you had to cheat to win. Don't make the game impossibly difficult or require paywalls/cheats to win and you won't have this problem.
TLDR: I can't help you address the crowd's mentality, but hopefully this feedback helps you find middle ground. My advice would be to stick to your guns. Waffling makes it harder to focus and will likely leave you frustrated and overwhelmed in the end.
TBH I think the easiest way out of the hole is to make this a pure vanilla harem game and just re-use the assets, writing and coding to make an NTR companion game. So when this reaches 1.0 or w/e version you plan on adding NTR into take the entire game package and make it into a new game called maybe "Corruption of the Elven Village" with the NTR content added to it. That or make the NTR a DLC package that needs to be added to the base game to access. Does it change the fact that you're both a vanilla and an NTR dev? No, but it gives the less than most extreme NTR haters an extra layer of disconnect from the NTR side that might reduce the bad taste in their mouth. Won't help you with the most extreme haters but it'll help you with the NTR haters who quite as insecure about it.Does that lower the quality of the scenes? Am I phoning in the vanilla side of the game just to get the ntr?
'Cause the last time I checked, I cared about the scenes and the dialogue I've written.
That's the thing I don't get about pure-vanilla people in regards to my game, you know that there's going to be NTR, so yeah in a sense, the girls that you're trying to win over may get content that you absolutely despite. but because the sole existance of NTR in the future, then that just diminishes all the content of the vanilla side? Furthermore, So far the only content in the game is vanilla, and it's going to be like that for several patches.
I just don't know how to deal with the whole pure-vanilla mindset, if I say, "no, vanilla peeps are my focus" how does that change anything? Like people said in pages before, even if that's the answer, I think, rightfully so, many people will still have their doubts and overall refuse to support a dev that's going to add NTR in the future, so I'm screwed in that regard.
And if I say the contrary; then I'm just using vanilla peeps while I secretly desire to make a NTR game? Like I can't win against that, and just trying to find the middle ground with that tribe is not possible. At the end of the day, I'm still working on content that they enjoy or want (Vanilla), content that I also enjoy making regardless of the label, so again, which one is it going to be? I'm just finding me in a dammed if I do, dammed if I don't situation constantly.
If you have an answer to that, I would love to hear it, but if you don't, then I think this game, or me as dev, just might not be for you.
Heck, I think you could also see it as me wanting to create a NTR game and still gettting a hopefully pretty good vanilla harem as a by-product, you don't see the NTR folks geting upset because the vanilla folks got taken care of, do you?
This sounds like you intended for the 'vanilla' part to be a basis for NTR, not that NTR was some option added later. Is that true?Does that lower the quality of the scenes? Am I phoning in the vanilla side of the game just to get the ntr?
'Cause the last time I checked, I cared about the scenes and the dialogue I've written.
That's the thing I don't get about pure-vanilla people in regards to my game, you know that there's going to be NTR, so yeah in a sense, the girls that you're trying to win over may get content that you absolutely despite. but because the sole existance of NTR in the future, then that just diminishes all the content of the vanilla side? Furthermore, So far the only content in the game is vanilla, and it's going to be like that for several patches.
I just don't know how to deal with the whole pure-vanilla mindset, if I say, "no, vanilla peeps are my focus" how does that change anything? Like people said in pages before, even if that's the answer, I think, rightfully so, many people will still have their doubts and overall refuse to support a dev that's going to add NTR in the future, so I'm screwed in that regard.
And if I say the contrary; then I'm just using vanilla peeps while I secretly desire to make a NTR game? Like I can't win against that, and just trying to find the middle ground with that tribe is not possible. At the end of the day, I'm still working on content that they enjoy or want (Vanilla), content that I also enjoy making regardless of the label, so again, which one is it going to be? I'm just finding me in a dammed if I do, dammed if I don't situation constantly.
If you have an answer to that, I would love to hear it, but if you don't, then I think this game, or me as dev, just might not be for you.
Heck, I think you could also see it as me wanting to create a NTR game and still gettting a hopefully pretty good vanilla harem as a by-product, you don't see the NTR folks geting upset because the vanilla folks got taken care of, do you?
I'd add let the MC fight too and add equipment for the girls and the MC to the game. I want the Adventurers Clothing Emiru claims she gave me and that Amulet and Sword dammit! You could maybe add expeditions, where you send some girls out and depending on their stats they can bring back some loot, if you don't want to just dump it all into an item shop.So combat still bugs out on the second week. Before that, though, I was able to test a few things:
- Dual Gun girls are still very, very bad and need a major buff. They even seem to have a lower stat leveling chance.
- Reina is also extremely bad, and also has a bad leveling seed.
- Sword and Shield Goblins are overtuned, and will mess you up if the RNG spawns too many of them.
- Wizard Goblins need to spawn more.
What I think you should do:
- Completely remove the RNG from leveling. It is painful, and some girls have a huge advantage when leveling for some reason (Honoka, for example), while others just get punished for no reason (Dual Gun girls, for example).
- Have the girls gain stats according to what weapons they wield and what you want them to counter. You cannot customise the girls, so there is no point in RNG stats. Unless you plan to animate them with all weapon types?
- Give Sword and Shield Goblins a proper counter.
If every battle is going to be to the death, then set stats when leveling are essential. Otherwise, someone might get no Attack and Defense a few levels in a row, and then be completely screwed. It would just cause people to rage like that recent review, or to savescum constantly, like me.
I think he plans to add that eventually, seeing as one of the girls is a blacksmith and I remember there being a mine?I'd add let the MC fight too and add equipment for the girls and the MC to the game. I want the Adventurers Clothing Emiru claims she gave me and that Amulet and Sword dammit! You could maybe add expeditions, where you send some girls out and depending on their stats they can bring back some loot, if you don't want to just dump it all into an item shop.
I think a potential issue is because of how funding a creator on Patreon works - people aren't funding a specific project or type of content, they're supporting the creator. Some creators have separate Patreon pages for their more standard games and their niche/controversial fetish games (inceton as an example) because vanilla fans, even if it's in the future, don't want to contribute towards something they dislike. It might be a good idea to do something similar if you plan to keep developing for opposing audiences.Does that lower the quality of the scenes? Am I phoning in the vanilla side of the game just to get the ntr?
'Cause the last time I checked, I cared about the scenes and the dialogue I've written.
That's the thing I don't get about pure-vanilla people in regards to my game, you know that there's going to be NTR, so yeah in a sense, the girls that you're trying to win over may get content that you absolutely despite. but because the sole existance of NTR in the future, then that just diminishes all the content of the vanilla side? Furthermore, So far the only content in the game is vanilla, and it's going to be like that for several patches.
I just don't know how to deal with the whole pure-vanilla mindset, if I say, "no, vanilla peeps are my focus" how does that change anything? Like people said in pages before, even if that's the answer, I think, rightfully so, many people will still have their doubts and overall refuse to support a dev that's going to add NTR in the future, so I'm screwed in that regard.
And if I say the contrary; then I'm just using vanilla peeps while I secretly desire to make a NTR game? Like I can't win against that, and just trying to find the middle ground with that tribe is not possible. At the end of the day, I'm still working on content that they enjoy or want (Vanilla), content that I also enjoy making regardless of the label, so again, which one is it going to be? I'm just finding me in a dammed if I do, dammed if I don't situation constantly.
If you have an answer to that, I would love to hear it, but if you don't, then I think this game, or me as dev, just might not be for you.
Heck, I think you could also see it as me wanting to create a NTR game and still gettting a hopefully pretty good vanilla harem as a by-product, you don't see the NTR folks geting upset because the vanilla folks got taken care of, do you?