- Sep 7, 2025
- 182
- 419
- 114
I love that you're both wrestling with this - it means the characters feel real enough to care about! But I want to offer some food for thought: The medieval fantasy world isn't meant to be viewed through a modern lens. In our fictional era, this isn't a back-alley operation existing in the shadows of legality. The King himself sanctions this establishment, collects taxes from it, and actively wants it to succeed. Think of Inara from Firefly - a Registered Companion who is legally protected, professionally trained, and socially respected. That's closer to what we're building here than the modern stigma around sex work. Sophie isn't being pushed into something shameful - she's being offered a position in a royally-sanctioned establishment with legal protections, regular income, housing, and genuine social standing. The "choice" question changes considerably when the work itself carries dignity and respect in that society's value system.
And here's where it gets really interesting from a narrative perspective: Sashina - the "wise mentor," the mystical guide who seems so benevolent, is actually the puppet master behind this entire situation. She manipulated the King's dreams to make him grant the brothel. She manipulates the player into running it. She manipulates certain... let's say "unconventional" individuals into joining the workforce. And she does all of this not from wisdom or greed, but from terror. She has seen VOID in her visions. She has witnessed the absolute nothingness of universal erasure. That cosmic horror drives every manipulation she makes. So the real moral dilemma isn't about any individual worker's agency - it's this: If VOID's plan is to erase all existence by destroying authentic human connection, does that justify building relationships through unconventional means?
Or...
And here's where it gets really interesting from a narrative perspective: Sashina - the "wise mentor," the mystical guide who seems so benevolent, is actually the puppet master behind this entire situation. She manipulated the King's dreams to make him grant the brothel. She manipulates the player into running it. She manipulates certain... let's say "unconventional" individuals into joining the workforce. And she does all of this not from wisdom or greed, but from terror. She has seen VOID in her visions. She has witnessed the absolute nothingness of universal erasure. That cosmic horror drives every manipulation she makes. So the real moral dilemma isn't about any individual worker's agency - it's this: If VOID's plan is to erase all existence by destroying authentic human connection, does that justify building relationships through unconventional means?
Or...
Last edited: