Nope. The fact is she was forced into her first and consequent sexual situations to save and protect Alan. Even if she took the penalties, she was still put under distressing situations and ending up having an argument with Alan. Either way, she was getting fucked mentally and physically.
She dies if she tries to do it the hard way. It just became a snowball effect after that.
But putting all that aside, when did talking to each other clearly become a point in ntr stories? If that was the case, then no ntr plot would exist
If every character were true geniuses then no ntr plot would exist. It just seems funny to discuss these things when every problem can be solved with the right logic. But that's the point of netorare stories. Logic shouldn't take precedent always unless you don't want ntr to happen.
Let's take the good old blackmail plot of ntr stories where the girl gets fucked to protect her man. Why can't she just tell her man everything and avoid getting fucked? Even if something bad happens, they can just face it together instead of hurting each other which is worse from a relationship pov. That relationship is already destroyed in my eyes. But so what? I just keep reading or playing to see what happens next for fun.