You were wrong about her being trapped inside herself in a 'I have no mouth and I must scream' style. And I really don't get what you're saying, just because she isn't the same as she used to be doesn't mean she isn't human. If she'd had an accident, head injury, and had complete amnesia would you still be so quick to want to kill her?
Last time I swear...
Not even comparable.
Amnesia is still that person just missing memories, chances are the memories will return at some point but regardless they are still them.
Chloe has been completely shattered, for all intents and purposes she's dead. She has no personality because he broke it completely. What is left is a mockery of life waiting to be moulded by someone else because it's incapable of doing it itself.
Looking at it from an even weirder point is the lie she's living with Alice. You said it yourself that Chloe is no longer in there so any affection shown to her sister is all muscle memory, it's not real affection. How long do you think before her sister realises she's not the same?
People keep bringing up the mind control aspect but that's not my issue. I don't mind altering perception to get a fuck, that isn't changing anything drastic. Chloe had her personality killed, there is no disputing that so this is beyond mind control to complete mind breaking.
Using a similar analogy to yours, it would be like being in an accident and coming out as a vegetable. Your body still functions but nobodies home.
Whatever is left of Chloe is going through the motions. People keep arguing that murdering her would be wrong yet even you have agreed that what was Chloe is dead so on a technical level we've already killed her, her body just doesn't know it.
She's like a computer waiting for an OS to be installed.
Like others have said, we're never going to see eye to eye on this. Although, according to the most moronic logic i've seen used on this forum and we've both seen people say some dumb shit, disliking 1 tiny portion of the game suddenly means I hate everything and am somehow telling the dev what to do.....
Real talk though, how the fuck did someone manage to come to that conclusion?
If a person was to reach into their own arse to pull that kind of reasoning out they would have to reach far enough to flick their own tonsils ... no one has arms that long.