False equivalence but I'll bite anyways. We fuck if we want to, as well we can decide to not to (and that includes Cait) Don't try to lump the MC into the fact that Cait was written to be the town's bike you like her or not.
Don't give me that. How is it false equivalence? Regardless of how she was written, from the perspective of the character, Caits fucks IF she wants to and can also decide not to. Almost everyone playing this will have their champion fuck with at least 50% of all npcs without regard for any romantic/loyalty obligations(like spouses or children) because they want to see most of the content. The MC of these games is almost unavoidably a huge cheat, if we treat the issue of fucking around this seriously.
To (you) if you want to be involved with her. Who else?
To be unfaithful, you have to make some sort of promise of exclusivity or faithfulness first. Even if there's was some (unfortunately)throwaway line about the champ thinking they and Cait starting to become "serious", there was no such promise. Cait doesn't demand ANYTHING of the champion either. Your MC demands loyalty but offers none, c'mon.
Since the beginning her personality always is of "Being stuck" with you (you like it or not) and you can't get rid of her to get a bit of respite. YOU ARE ALWAYS DEPENDANT OF HER UNTIL YOU GET A SOMEWHAT COMPETENT HEALER. And her demeanor of "Old nagging hag" is a huge turn off even to those who try to RP in the game.
Sure only 1 healer is a problem, then again Ryn becomes available quickly. I didn't really notice the nagging aspect tho.
Kasyrra is most likely an embodiment of Slaanesh (fa/tg/uy) because she's all about "sex, drugs and rock n' roll" while cait is most likely a soup of any STD ever existed in Savarra.
Why do you think Kasyrra, or Slaanesh for that matter, doesn't have stds? If Cait has a "a soup of any STD ever existed in Savarra" because of all the fucking she does, then so does Kasyrra who fucks more, in both Savarra and Mareth. If Cait's like Nurgle than so is Kasyrra. And also, as I mentioned, Kas'sfluids literally poison the environment and mutate the wildlife.
I get that you like Cait man, but you're will face a huge tide of people that is tired of her and want to get rid of her ASAP (myself included)
That's fine, but the exaggerated hate for her gets kind of comical at some point.