I save Robin one time and I get this:
I never fight. A lifelong victim is somehow a sadist for saving Robin once? Maybe I'll rethink helping her...
BTW, we should be able to return to Remy willingly. Just enter the farm and see an option "Apologize to Remy for running away", which gets you captured again without Obedience loss, or "Try to strike a deal with Remy" so you you can agree to return to the farm often or be captured, like Eden. Remy's response could be based on her current Love, or even the character's current Bovinity, since Remy likes you to be transformed and busty af. (Hard to hate Remy...)
It seems to me that a cow girl would
want to visit the farm, graze, be milked,
fuck pigs ... So I figure an option to return to the farm willingly should exist, as long as there's some agreement that you can still return to town to handle things like earning money so you can pay Bailey, and building stats and relationships, or advance in church, like me. I actually maintained a legit relationship with Eden for months in my last game, so the "return or else" mechanic is manageable.