I mean, "Not being nice" doesn't always have to mean "be an edgelord", you know? I go the defiant route, beat the piss out of rapists, intervene and fight bullies who are harassing others, that kind of thing. Can't really bring myself to turn down those that are weaker or in need. Atleast not in my current playthrough.
Also, you know how there is a "Hope" mechanic at the orphanage? I like to imagine there is also one in town, since my character was approached by two women saying "Hey, you're the one that beats up rapists, right? Teach us your ways!", so I'm glad my character became and example, a beacon of hope! Nothing like vigilante justice!
Ey', how about our characters team up, huh?
Kind of like this...?