At risk of sounding like a total fanboy, I'll just say it. Man...this game is so charming! Caught me completely off guard. It's wholesome, funny, and cute; in a sort of effortlessly flowing way.
Okay, I'll stop gushing like Annie's first time getting fingered, and give it a proper rating.
Visual: I wasn't initially a fan of the Honey Select look, but it really grew on me. In hindsight, I think it fits the mood and theme of the game perfectly. I really appreciate a dev that goes the extra mile, and Caribdis definitely went the extra mile. You can feel the passion poured into the scenes, especially the later ones. I rewinded quite a few just to watch them again.
Audio: I don't think there's a single scene that doesn't have accompanying sound. And it all feels appropriate to the mood: the low background ambient sounds giving breathing room, while ramping music gives tension or dramatic flair.
Story wise, I found the premise very entertaining. It allows the story to weave through fantasy, sci-fi, wizardy etc... and still be rooted in the real world. Sorta the best of both worlds. The story does start abit slow, but as it progresses the dev hits his stride and the scenes flow very well from tense, to funny, to sad, to sexy.
The writing is also quite good. There are no spelling or grammar issues, and the wording fits the theme and tone very well. I found myself laughing at quite a few scenes, especially some of the running gags.
Overall the main protagonist is quite likeable too. He's a well-meaning teenager, who until recently didn't have alot of luck with the ladies. And he genuinely wants well for all the girls, which is quite nice. I do have some minor grips. I mean, my man is so pale, it makes me wonder if he's part vampire. And his cock is a bit too big. (But many other AVNs have this problem too. I swear devs are in some sort of arms race to see who can render the biggest cock. Soon, the MC will just be a giant cock walking on two balls)
But I digress. The game maybe isn't for everyone's sensabilities. It has a slight anime feel in it's theme, graphics, and humor (which is a plus for me...maybe not for everyone). It is surprisingly light-hearted and wholesome, although with a few dips into dark or sentimental moments. It actually doesn't have many sex scenes, and the first one comes a few hrs into gameplay (depending on your reading speed). If these artistic decisions don't connect with you, then the game will probably be a miss. But if it does, man you are in for a treat!
Connecting...to Eternum.