Female Protagonist vs. Male Protagonist

[SurvivalMyths]

If I'm ever given the choice, I'll pretty much always go for the male protagonist option just for immersion purposes.

However I don't really have much of a problem with female protagonists either. I guess my preference really depends on the type of game I'm playing though. Generally I'm more for characters that have a bit of depth to them. So if it's obvious the game was tailored towards one side, then I'll usually go for whatever the developer / developers intended.

 

[Deleted member 6598995]

Male protagonists for me, simply because I can immerse myself better into them.

Been tempted to try one with a female protagonist, to see if they are any different. Haven't tried it yet but most likely will do so in the future when I get sick of playing these sad excuses of male protagonists in some of the games I try.

 

[bearclaw01234]

It depends on the game as to which gender is preferable. If it's a VN with incest or harem, then I prefer a Male MC (many great RPG's are done with Male MC's as well. One of my RPG favorites with a Male MC is the Queen Opala Series where a Female MC would just feel wrong. Though RPG games like Roundscape Adorevia are good with either gender). While most games tend to go the route of Male MC seduces Female NPC's for whatever reason, the memorable ones for me are where ye get the choice how to act with them (to which I tend to make it a romantic venture of love & sexual intimacy).

As long as game isn't the tired & worn out trope of: "Female MC that goes around & gets fucked by everyone with little to no choice in the matter", then I choose a Female MC in VN, HTML, & RPG games where there's an actual story & a good adventure to it (like the RPG Desecration of Wings).

As for the games with Hermaphrodite, Futanari, & Transgender MC's: This is much better done with a Feminine MC as it looks much more attractive (by most people, including me) & most people to think of a wider range of possibilities with this being a Feminine MC rather than a Masculine one.

It's a moot point in Time-Management games considering there is very little to no sexual content & if there is some then it's not a key focus of the game & more just to give some excitement or "flavor" to the game.

Pertaining to PC Games: it's mostly just about the eye candy as to which gender ye prefer to see in it. I prefer a Female MC for the obvious reason (among others) that the female body is a true work of art.

Overall:
It all comes down to personal preference & viewpoint. Everyone's preferences are different & many can be similar (if not the same) as other's, but the reason for those preferences are what makes them unique.

 

[LionInDarkness]

Since we are all like-minded deviant scumbags circling the drains of humanity, I would like to strike up a discussion with y'all on the subject of Female vs. Male protagonists.

I personally prefer female protagonists. I often disregard male protagonist games right off the bat. Most of the male protagonist games just seem way too seedy to me; like you're posing as some stud just fucking your way through 'worthless' women. However, playing as a woman feels like you're somehow taking power over sexuality and making choices that changes the character. When playing as a male, I just get the sense, that, you know; 'men are creeps', from beginning to end, and it's just a question of how many notches you can get on your belt. With female protagonists you can get a sense of development, from inoccent to deviant. But with male protagonists, you just start, stay and end deviant. I would therefore argue that character development is significantly limited in most male protagonist games, whereas with female protagonist games, you can get a real sense of progression, of character evolvement, which ultimately results in way more interesting storylines.

Anyway, what you guys think? And if you prefer male protagonist games, I would love to understand why? Maybe if someone gave me some perspective on this matter, I could perhaps start enjoying those games as well, which would be good, cos (DAMN!) there are a lot of them games out there. It would be 'a whole new world' to me (like Aladdin dude!). Remeber that movie? That was a good movie, man.

Alright, thanks for you time and hopefully your input. Now I'm just gonna lean back and wait for that deviant mountain to come to Muhammad.

Love and peace, SAFFID.

I prefer male protag, why? Because i'm a guy. I'm that odd guy that usually will play as a guy even in normal games because I want to be the main character. I don't truly enjoy the idea of controlling a woman physically or mentally so playing as doesn't entice me too much. In simpler terms, i want to be with the woman not be her.
It's already bad enough that i 90 or so percent of games have a white mc (which I'm not) so playing as a guy is all i got. It seems that you're main issue with male protag is the same one i have which is most mc's are usually written horribly. They are horn dogs that couldnt care less about emotion or love and just want to fuck everything with little actual plot. This is why i enjoy games where the mc is pretty decent in general. I assure you that there are some games out there with male mc's that aren't walking trashbags. Recently played a few where the mc was decent and had me laughing. To be honest the only thing about female protag games that almost entice me is that alot of them seem to have allot of effort put in them from the screencaps i see on a good bit of them.

 

[praesegmen]

I don't have a problem with either, most games with male protagonist are boring without much character depth. Do you guys have any game recommendation with good male protagonist who isn't just horny fuckboy?

 

[Virulenz]

Those are just as rare as female protagonists who are no sluts.
Sex sells and lets be honest, most users are here for it. Personally i prefer a good story and a "real" sexlife, because most humans after puberty take what they get on the way and dont focus their whole life into getting sex. But those games are made by big devs and need mods to prevent fucking in underwear or fading out cutscenes. So far i still search for a healthy combination without needing a ton of mods and play with load orders...

 

[mekorama]

i just wanna fuck every women around the world,but female mc game is way more than male's one,so sometimes i dont even have a second choice

 

[DumpTruckLover]

damn, I didn't expect women to be more preferred. i like female protagonists, but my preference is usually for men. (that's a weird way of putting it)

 

[macadam]

damn, I didn't expect women to be more preferred. i like female protagonists, but my preference is usually for men. (that's a weird way of putting it)

normal.

females mc usually have more story and character design.

males mc usually are just the dumb nerd/macho/sexual mentaly ill mens that just think of sex instantly when they see a female npc.

also male mc are too repetitive in their design, while women seems to be more variant.

 

[Geigi]

normal.

females mc usually have more story and character design.

males mc usually are just the dumb nerd/macho/sexual mentaly ill mens that just think of sex instantly when they see a female npc.

also male mc are too repetitive in their design, while women seems to be more variant.

Not true. Most female protagonist games are either a whore maker or rape fest, so ofc they would be preferable among the majority of straight male players. They are no different than male protagonist games where the purpose is to be either ntr'd/cucked/sissified or have a harem. Even female players complain how there's more romance in male protagonist games/are pure vanilla. If fmcs are like romcoms, no straight male player would play them. I would really like to know which FMC game don't give a misogynistic vibe.

 

[macadam]

Not true. Most female protagonist games are either a whore maker or rape fest, so ofc they would be preferable among the majority of straight male players. They are no different than male protagonist games where the purpose is to be either ntr'd/cucked/sissified or have a harem. Even female players complain how there's more romance in male protagonist games/are pure vanilla. If fmcs are like romcoms, no straight male player would play them. I would really like to know which FMC game don't give a misogynistic vibe.

no no, i mean female are more versatil in style.

we rarely see female Mc looking similar from one game to another (unless it's the whole point of course). compared to male MC that most of them look similar in all point.

girl MC in my games are no just cum bucket or slut, i work tto give them some charisma and a bit of "life". so yes, they end up having sex, but rarely just in a blink of an eye. Mostly because i dont like the concept of playing someone that cant do anything without sucking a cock because it's a lock otherwise.

my commercial time

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Geigi]

no no, i mean female are more versatil in style.

we rarely see female Mc looking similar from one game to another (unless it's the whole point of course). compared to male MC that most of them look similar in all point.

girl MC in my games are no just cum bucket or slut, i work tto give them some charisma and a bit of "life". so yes, they end up having sex, but rarely just in a blink of an eye. Mostly because i dont like the concept of playing someone that cant do anything without sucking a cock because it's a lock otherwise.

my commercial time

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

OK, I'll check your game, thanks for the rec.

 

[Virulenz]

normal.

females mc usually have more story and character design.

males mc usually are just the dumb nerd/macho/sexual mentaly ill mens that just think of sex instantly when they see a female npc.

also male mc are too repetitive in their design, while women seems to be more variant.

Dont forget the core feature, they dont have dicks ^^

 

[macadam]

Dont forget the core feature, they dont have dicks ^^

well i dont mind that, female, male, futa etc.. i play whatever.

the main problem imho, is that when mc is a male, the dick is just always oversized ridiculously...i dont like that, i find it dumb.

 

[Virulenz]

Well, dicks ruin scenes for me, in many cases the whole game.

 

[seifukulover]

If you prefer female protag you're trans or gay, end of story.

If you actually believe this you are a dumbass, end of story.

 

[seifukulover]

I'll play both games but the ones that catch my interest the most tend to have male protagonists. Like many others here I'm male and can easily insert myself into most male protags.

But the fun of female protagonists is that it lets me roleplay as someone I'm not. Whenever I play RPGs for example, my male characters tend to be just "me, but in the RPG setting". But as a female character I have to develop a different mindset, and put myself into her shoes and think about how she would handle a situation.

I'm not a sexy dark-skinned teenage fighter girl, but when I play Violated Heroine I can pretend to be one for a little while. And I'm not attracted to men, but Nanako very much is... and I'm the one who decides how many dicks she gets and when. Who will be her first: the hot stud Henry walking around at night, the shota in the bath, or will she get raped by a goblin? Either way I'm going to jerk off to it, but I get to write her story at the same time. It's definitely a different experience from playing a male protagonist, not better or worse, just its own thing.