hysepReC

Well-Known Member
Feb 16, 2022
1,034
3,793
But hey, informal poll! Which girl is your favorite?
Brittani, with Madison second. I want what i'm not supposed to have, lol. I do wonder why Madison isn't more popular, she's the classic married MILF. I'm interested in seeing how the Nice Guy route will play out with her because she really loves her husband and seems a long way off cheating on him willingly.
 

ename144

Engaged Member
Sep 20, 2018
3,473
14,315
But hey, informal poll! Which girl is your favorite?
Probably Carolina, though admittedly we've seen very little of her and I may be projecting my preferences on a relatively blank slate. But so far she's attractive, mature and has a nicely sarcastic sense of humor. And Maya is cute, which doesn't hurt. Second place is Ashe; I definitely like her, but I get the impression my preferences would be a little boring for her long term.

Beyond that, the other girls go something like this:
  • Nicki: I like her as a friend, but by her own admission she's not in the right headspace for a proper relationship right now and I don't want to lead her on.
  • Brittanyi: I liked her a lot more than I was expecting to. The problem is that after her tear-filled soliloquy about how much she craved the normalcy of her boyfriend's family there's no way I'm pulling a creepy old man on her. She's just too effective an actress, I guess. :p
  • Madison: I've no interest in breaking up a (seemingly) happy marriage.
  • Gabby: I realize she'd be pissed off to hear me say it, but she just doesn't seem mature enough for such a lopsided relationship. Hopefully she'll grow up a bit if we keep things strictly above board.
  • Cassie: I'm so sick to death of incest that I'd pass even if I had the Taboo patch running.
  • Mason: Can't judge until their story actually starts.
  • Alex, Viola, Pepper: They've barely made an impression in the little I've interacted with them.
 
Last edited:

Ragnar

Super User
Respected User
Former Staff
Aug 5, 2016
5,127
14,181
1. Ashe, the perfect combination of airhead and cunning woman in a voluptuous body ready for some kinki action.
2. Viola, cause I'm a sucker for lost puppies.
3. Nicki, the fuck buddy and Brittany got milk?
 

PHIL101-YYouPPHard

Active Member
Jan 11, 2022
969
1,890
And I do have plans to tone down some elements of Chapter One, so it makes more sense when Nicki does come back.
NGL, that makes me a little worried :unsure: Hopefully nothing too drastic?

Honestly, if I just did what was popular, the menu screen would look like this. :'D

View attachment 2496111
"Also at least three girls have dicks now"
:LOL: You really know how to tempt a man and then snatch it away :cry::p

But hey, informal poll! Which girl is your favorite?
TBH man, it's constantly switching moment-to-moment because the writing is so good that I'm just down for w/e character comes my way :) It's very hard to choose. That said, maybe so far I'm leaning towards Gabbi. If the question becomes characters we haven't seen as much (if at all) that I'm most looking forward to, though... Mason looks interesting and like (s)he maybe has a kink or two that I'll like ;) And Cassie and the "mother" certainly has me extremely excited... can't wait to see what you come up with there!

BTW, er, um... you don't happen to have any GILF encounters planned, do you? It's just that GILFs, and I mean true GILFs not MILFs with white hair, are such a rare sight in VNs and it would be so fascinating to see the sexual and romantic perspective of an older gal from you. Maybe the gal that used to own the photoshoot apartment? :unsure: (maybe she moved away, though, can't remember) Obviously your plate of characters is already overflowing, so I'm sure you have no plans especially for a niche market, but even a minor character w/ one encounter would be so welcome and refreshing for us wrinkle freaks :ROFLMAO:
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: NeonGhosts

botc76

The Crawling Chaos, Bringer of Strange Joy
Donor
Oct 23, 2016
4,508
13,480
But hey, informal poll! Which girl is your favorite?

Hard choice to make, as I find something likeable in all girls and from some we have seen very little so far, and going by optics alone would make no sense.

Gabby probably is my favourite for now. I usually like more voluptuous ladies, but she has a nice tight body, I like her hair and I really like the mixture of both vulnerability and spunk, of relative sexual inexperience, but very willing to try stuff.
Brittany would be second now, initially I just really liked her visuals, but I am a sucker for sad stories and always want to help people in hard times (I use a mod to be able to adopt more children in Skyrim fe. :) ), plus her boyfriend is such a douche, I just have to free her of his idiocy.
Third would probably Ashe right now, sexy and very approachable, kind character. I like that.

There are several women I do find fascinating from what we've seen so far, Pepper, Carolina, Risa, but we've seen too little of them to be sure whether I like them more or less than others.

Nicki would probably rate higher, if not for 2 reasons, she is definitely not my type visually AND while I (as the MC) might have forgiven her for what she did, it's still pretty shitty how she treated the MC. There are reasons, yeah, but that doesn't mean I don't hold a bit of resentment.


And while I don't want to start an argument or something, I am seriously wondering, what is your LGBTQ agenda?
The only thing I can think of is that Mason seems quite genderfluid for now, but I admit I just figured they were a girl trying to hide that fact, to live a little safer on the streets.

But even if they are trans or non-binary, one character out of so many wouldn't exactly make much of an agenda.

OTOH, gamer bros already scream woke agenda over a single trans NSC in a game with a few hundred characters, or claim that the new Dead Space is woke (still not sure why, maybe one straight white male too few for them :cool: )
 
  • Heart
Reactions: NeonGhosts

tuskedkibbles

Member
Mar 27, 2018
135
358
Probably Carolina, though admittedly we've seen very little of her and I may be projecting my preferences on a relatively blank slate. But so far she's attractive, mature and has a nicely sarcastic sense of humor. And Maya is cute, which doesn't hurt. Second place is Ashe; I definitely like her, but I get the impression my preferences would be a little boring for her long term.

Beyond that, the other girls go something like this:
  • Nicki: I like her as a friend, but by her own admission she's not in the right headspace for a proper relationship right now and I don't want to lead her on.
  • Brittany: I liked her a lot more than I was expecting to. The problem is that after her tear-filled soliloquy about how much she craved the normalcy of her boyfriend's family there's no way I'm pulling a creepy old man on her. She's just too effective an actress, I guess. :p
  • Madison: I've no interest in breaking up a (seemingly) happy marriage.
  • Gabby: I realize she'd be pissed off to hear me say it, but she just doesn't seem mature enough for such a lopsided relationship. Hopefully she'll grow up a bit if we keep things strictly above board.
  • Cassie: I'm so sick to death of incest that I'd pass even if I had the Taboo patch running.
  • Mason: Can't judge until their story actually starts.
  • Alex, Viola, Pepper: They've barely made an impression in the little I've interacted with them.
This is probably the most 'level headed' answer I've seen, and I've got to agree. I'm in my late 20's. I just don't have the mental energy to deal with high school level immaturity. Gabby 100% acts her age. Solution there is honestly just time and experience. The only character so far I would describe as 'a kid'.

Brittney's a little better (largely due to her issues being much more serious/abuse related so I personally am willing to be more patient with it), but honestly I don't think I'd be willing to try and defuse that bomb. If you do defuse it though she'd probably be a great partner.

Madison I agree. I'm no homewrecker.

Ashe is a bit ditzy for my taste to be honest. She isn't shallow, but she isn't my type either (tragic since I love blondes). Perhaps fitting given the game events thus far, but Ashe strikes me as a one night stand and that's all.

Carolina definitely has it together. Easily the most mature (from what we've seen so far) of the lot. She does have a kid though, which shouldn't be taken lightly since you're adding two people to your life, not just one.

Not much to go on so far for the others.
 

fashtar

Member
Mar 23, 2019
286
257
But hey, informal poll! Which girl is your favorite?
First place is honestly between Viola and Brittani. Our interaction with Viola so far is very, very brief (assuming you choose not to be an asshole), but it shows a lot of potential room for developing a relationship with her, and I like where that is going. In both directions, actually.

Brittani, on the other hand, is a gorgeous, determined, and fairly bright young woman who wants to become an actress to the point she mentally clicks in between. I've always had huge respect for actors since they can actually keep track of the various personalities they have to keep track of when they're doing their job. Brittani shows a lot of potential as an aspiring actress and her boyfriend honestly doesn't deserve her. Better she goes to me, instead.

For the others...

2: Ashe, because everyone likes a hot blonde every now and then.
3: Risa. Instant impression, but I have yet to see anything with her.
4: Nicki. Good friend, possible submissive servant, either way, she is reliable.
5: Gabby. Feels a bit forced on me, but I'll play along since she is cute in her own way, but I've never liked the "angry at my parents for keeping me in the dark, and I show it by lashing out at others without care for what they have say" type.
6: Cassie. I have done so many incest games on this site, this'll be nothing new to me. The only real difference is that Cassie has only made appearances in photos or dreams.

The others, I don't know enough to give a good rating. Need more input and data for a fair judgment.
 
  • Heart
Reactions: NeonGhosts

GrimCiri

Amateur Developer
Game Developer
Apr 8, 2018
70
455
But hey, informal poll! Which girl is your favorite?
For me it's Nicki by quite a ways, I like her look the most and her story is the most interesting/developed.
From their Brittani and Viola I think by looks and type of content with them.
Then Madison and Mason I am most interesting in what their content might bring.
Then finally Gabby and Ashe I am not really interested in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NeonGhosts

CrazyRabbit

Engaged Member
Oct 30, 2019
2,216
10,646
But hey, informal poll! Which girl is your favorite?
Gabby ofc ; but I find my second place a tie between Brittani and Viola ; i can smell drama on the both of them and they are so cute....
And 3rd place, despite her decision making skill rivaling Activision Blizzard and John Romero combined, Nikki ; against my better judgement I must say....

I'll keep an eye out for Ashe and Mason, who knows.
 

PHIL101-YYouPPHard

Active Member
Jan 11, 2022
969
1,890
And while I don't want to start an argument or something, I am seriously wondering, what is your LGBTQ agenda?
The only thing I can think of is that Mason seems quite genderfluid for now, but I admit I just figured they were a girl trying to hide that fact, to live a little safer on the streets.
Yeah, I was wondering the same thing... some people are really, really sensitive I guess? Like, I understand if you're being preached at, although I don't think anyone likes it when things are too on-the-nose, even if they're in support of it, as that's just bad writing imo. But everything Neon's written so far is just traditional good VN stuff, i.e. put a character forward to the player and let them decide on what to do. Like everyone else, I have my own political opinions and what not on sex and gender today (among other things), but my god, ree-ing over something as minor as the mere inclusion of (what appears to be) an LGBT character is just embarrassing and makes whoever these guys are look like terminally online weirdos :LOL: 'Variety is the spice of life' is a motto I agree with here.
 

Walnutt

Member
Jan 14, 2021
262
611
But hey, informal poll! Which girl is your favorite?
Brittani number one with Nikki as a close second. Nikki is a fuck up but c'mon, she was *fucked* by the bf (legit forgot his name). The only mistake she made was going back. She got rammed up the ass with everything after that. And honestly, she has some huge fucking ovaries to get out of the situation she was in and make it back to MC safely. Bad things can happen to anyone with just the smallest bad decision. I think she definitely gets way more hate/non-interest than she deserves

But coming in at a surprise #3 based solely on looks is Risa! Legit so excited to see what's gonna be up with her!
 
  • Like
Reactions: NeonGhosts

Xypher

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2017
1,294
1,447
I will say this -- I don't let the popularity of any of the girls dictate how much screentime they get. If anyone goes back and reads this thread when I first showed Gabby's character design, reviews were not kind. But, I knew I could make people love her, once they got to know her. I also regularly get excoriated on a few pirate sites for pushing my 'LGBT agenda,' but I think next chapter will show I'm not shying away from things that might piss people off.

The truth is, girls like Nicki, Gabby, and Brittani are well-represented for the moment, because that's where the story's at. Nicki's drama began the story and then came back in force with Chapter 3, but now she's easing into a supporting role. Gabby's story with her dad is a persistent mystery, and MC's pending redesign of the bookstore gives him a lot of reasons to be there, interacting with Gabby and Madison. Gabby's story is directly connected with Brittani, which then feeds into her drama surrounding her and her family.

But, as was teased in the last update, there's something swirling around Ashe that MC needs to investigate, Carolina's constantly in his periphery, and Viola's home situation is due for some attention. Eventually, everyone will get their shine. Some people just need MC more right now. But, once their needs are met, he can move on to helping other people.

Honestly, if I just did what was popular, the menu screen would look like this. :'D

View attachment 2496111

As for polls, I'd like to start polling for popularity once everyone's gotten their fair share of screentime. Right now it'd be really skewed, I think. In the short term, my plan is to do polls for which under-represented character people would like to see a scene with, and then use the winner to decide who gets a date/sex scene, provided it fits into the framework of the chapter.

When it comes to my favorite? Oof! Tough question! I love them all for different reasons. I try to give all of them distinct voices that make them all fun to write dialogue for, and they all serve different interests of mine. Tomboy, brat, bimbo, MILF, goth, Russian, muscles.. The broad descriptors of each girl are basically my PornHub search history. :'D But then I get to subvert those in interesting ways. Nicki's a tomboy who occasionally likes to show her girly side to her crush. Gabby's a brat who's really got a big, sensitive heart. Ashe is a bimbo with some surprising depth and empathy. On and on.

Right now, I'm finding the most fun in combining characters for scenes, letting them riff off each other. I'm in the plotting stage for Chapter 5, and I've been sketching out a dialogue scene between Risa and Maya that I think will be terrific.

View attachment 2496131

Buuuuut, gun to my head, my favorite is probably Nicki. I love her model, and her 'voice' is super comfortable for me to write in. My top three would likely be Nicki, Gabby, and Alex.

But hey, informal poll! Which girl is your favorite?
I really like your take of giving stereotypical girls more depth and characters.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NeonGhosts

Xypher

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2017
1,294
1,447
But hey, informal poll! Which girl is your favorite?
So far, 1st best in no order would be Nicki, Gabby and Brittani

2nd best would be Ashe and Viola.

No opinion for now since not much exploration of character or content: Madison, Carolina, Mason, Cassie.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NeonGhosts

goulet1995

Well-Known Member
Sep 30, 2021
1,499
3,055
Top tier-Brittani Nickie(any more fuck ups and she drops)
2nd tier-Viola(potential 1st tier) madison
bottom tier- gabi and mason
the rest i need more time with cassie will likely be top tier unless like i expect it forces bi stuff for her
 
  • Like
Reactions: NeonGhosts
4.60 star(s) 220 Votes