I've always appreciated this thread! "Gay protagonist" really should be a tag, but again its a challenge with the anti-gay chatter and obtuse usage of the "gay" tag.
It's hard to find games where you play a "male that wants to have sex with other males" with current tagging.
"Gay protagonist" tag also doesn't work.
The perfect example is this thread, There are YAOI, Bara, Bi, Twink, Underaged / Boy, Femboy, Trap, Trans, Sissification...
Pretty sure each of them serves a different group of audiences (even tho there'll be overlap depends on each person).
Unless the tag system differentiate what type of game it is with tags like I listed, (apparently the site doesn't intended to do),
your best bet is to judge each game with tags you are interested manually.
It's not Hard, you think it is cuz there just aren't as many games.
Thank you for collating this huge list of games, I'm just wondering if anyone's ever seen any threads on this website which actually made some tier-lists of these games?
There's no way you can come up a "Tier-List" for Gay porn games, the range is just too wide
That's why you can't find one, especially one you can agree with unless it's made by yourself.