So I occasionally look in on ‘male protagonist’ games not tagged as gay because it can be nice to watch a straight guy getting off (solo or in female company) – as long as they’re not represented solely by a disembodied penis (between two zeppelins) or a detached hand (“Thank you, Thing”). Maybe it’s a voyeur thing.
I came across an entry on Itcho tagged ‘LGBT’ (but not specifically gay), but still may find a place on this list:
You must be registered to see the links
A compelling story involving mysterious mental powers and some very strange goings on in a school setting. The protagonist is apparently comfortably hetero but watches straight, gay or trans porn (player’s choice) without a flicker of conflict (and brings us along for the ride); tries out anal toys with great success (and brings us along for the ride); has no problem teasing his straight male friends in Truth or Dare; those straight friends do such a weak job of homosexual panic you wonder why they bother. He has brains, spunk, agency and uh, spunk.
Interesting game mechanic with stats for libido, discipline and morality, increased by gameplay that has an impact on story.
Lesbians fully represented, complex social issues engaged. Starts out relatively light but goes into quite dark areas. The kinks are many.
Worst element: the guy’s haircut.