Just because a game features fetishes you aren't into it doesn't mean that it "lost potential". But it would be preferable if niche content was optional/avoidable. Also I don't see how this group of people is "overly vocal", I rarely ever hear things you listed mentioned.
People tend to enter the discussion to suggest their niche desires. The developer stated in the earlier pages that they want their game to be more "community driven" and that they'll implement fetishes which are popularly requested. While this is not inherently a bad idea, a community can differ depending on where you are asking for the feedback. If you go to a website which is designed for people who fetishize women who look like Arnold Schwarzenegger in his prime, and you want their suggestions, you know what kind of suggestion you're going to get.
In the case of F95, the website is not designed for any specific type of person. But a vocal minority still exists here and can still effectively convince someone that something is popular when it isn't. Fortunately, reading the thread, the developer is aware of this and only really plans to add the other stuff once the game is better fleshed out so that everybody can enjoy it first. As they say, it'll come later as expansions to the mistresses.
But, you can see it in this thread itself in regards to BBW and "fat worship" being added, for example. And someone asking if something like scat is planned to be involved, or if it would be avoidable if so. This is all evidence of vocal minority groups having a presence elsewhere that we now need to ask "is X going to be added? Will it be avoidable?" And yes, the sexual desire for BBW/larger-set ladies that we see in games like ToT and UTW is heavily a fetish and not exactly mainstream. I know people disagree with that.
They ask for plans of futanari, plans for scat and farting, etc. They are a minority group so of course, they are not so commonly seen unless you are perhaps looking for them. They also don't exist solely on F95. But they are still vocal, probably because they understand the only way to achieve any sort of acknowledgement is to have the confidence (or desperation?) to ask, or to have the money to pay for those additions themselves if developer(s) are allowing people to pay to suggest what they should do next.
I fucking love your trolling
Personaly im not into fat girls historically women who have fought did have some meat on the bone so not anime proportions realisem has nothing to to fucking do here this redhead looks like a model
So hefty well built women woild make sense here like the intro dom
No need to shame people im joming shame people
If you are referring to Maeve as the 'redhead', I personally think she looks great. She's still fit and toned. The developer has stated in the earlier pages that they plan to make their characters look like models or pin-up girls so if she does look like a model then the developer/artist has done a good job.
Edela (the intro domme) already exists for people who like "meaty" girls (this is just another way to say fat, sorry to say) and I'm sure she'll get content eventually. But too many girls like Edela and then this might as well just be ToT 2. The upcoming orc blacksmith, from what I've seen, looks bigger than Maeve in musculature but still smaller than Edela in body fat.
I personally have to agree with YugataKisu, trolling or not. Especially in regards to Jessica of ToT.