Counter argument:
1. Alice instructing new maids would probably make her happy. It's not about replacing her. It's about using her as the core of the island's growing maid service.
2. Regardless of anything else, Sarah should end up a maid. That's on a basic narrative level. She is "The Haughty One who needs to Fall". The irony of making her a maid, the role that she spent the most time disparaging is thus powerful.
3. Scarlet, I think, has less reason to become a maid, and if she ran the tech store it would make sense. That said, since there is the sister theme going on, it would make more sense to place her the same spot as Sarah, but be genuinely happy about it.
This works better on a narrative level too. If you exile her to the electronics store, then she doesn't have another charachter to play off of. She's more fun when not in isolation.
4. Regarding the "BDSM simulator note". Why would either of them becoming a maid require more BDSM? You do more BDSM with Sonya then you do with Alice. However, maids are a kink. And I can't help but notice right now that neither really has a kink built into their charachter and they're both very sexually flavorless.
5. Oh yeah. Because there are no hijinks that can be done with two people used to wealth learning how to be maids. No hijinks at all.
1. Totaly not. Please read the first Scenes with her introduction again. Leah mentioned that Alice don´t want any help. And is happy to do her Part. Every Girl has her Part on the Island. So no Position is settled with 2 Girls.
2.There is a Maid, and First of all the Game is a funny Game. So there should be something very special. Like she must reopen the Farm and work hard for her Food. But in my Opinion Maid is over the edge.
3. Less Reason? First Argument, there are some request about the opening Times of the Electronic Store, and this will be a elegant way to get it open any Time. And second the MC mentioned that he will make her Happy. And working there, get some confidence will be the way. Not stick her together with her Bitch of Sis. This will never lead to confidence, cause Scarlet was never the Revenge type of Person.
4.Sonya BDSM stuff is a Demo, a testing Platform for the Dev. (You can read in Post before and ingame too) Sonya is in Bondage, nothing more so far.
5. Every Girl has her own Fetish
But so far as I see, every Girl has her own Main-Fetish. Yes some borders are open. But every Girl has it. And this is a main Part of the Charme of this Game. You must think and approach every Girl in other Ways.
hachigames has find a great way to show this in his Quests and Design of the Game, every Girl is special, and unique.
6. Last but not least. In my Opinion what you ask is too real for this Game. This Game is totaly funny and surreal. The Dialogues the setting all shows you that nothing is to casual to play. The Game in last update is the best example, nothing to hard. All about frindship. All sex in this Game is more like a Game between friends. And in my opinion you take it too serious. At least for this game. Don´t take it the way most games go. Even the MC and the allmighty Dicktator himself are no serious Charakters.
So I hope that
hachigames will stick to this, and tell us a Story with sarcasm, Fun, and some nice Plottwist. Cause I am enjoying this Game right from the beginning. I have seen so many Games that all go down cause they go to Mainstream. And this is the most relaxing Game I have played a long time. Nothing is too serious, and the Scenes make fun to read. Only thing I miss in this Game is some Music, but this I compensate with a Carribean playlist.