while i agree with your reasoning i don't think this is what will happen, i think in the next Rose update she will properly get creampied and N_Tai was just saving it for later as it would be way different than what N_Tai did in HC1 AND HC2. ideally i would rather she does not get creampied until the endings as then i can somehow see the happy ending making sense as i see it as the point of no return.It's not about depravity or defilement, the reason why Rose doesn't have a creampie scene is because she's the heir to the throne and it would be less then ideal for both the Duke and Rose if she got pregnant at this time.
That being said i DO hope that she gets a creampie scene before the endings cause i think that if every other girl got creampied then she shouldn't be able get out squeaky clean in the Happy and the Revenge endings.
Would be quite boring if it would stay at anal only for rose until endings ngl.I thought I had forgotten, but she doesn't really have creampie, huh? But I think it will probably be in her last update, it doesn't make sense to save that for for a maybe happy route, she did a LOT of anal and that it's more defiled than creampie.
I haven't followed this discussion in depth but so far HC1 and 2 had a true end so it feels weird not having it in HC3. What is the reasoning behind it?I can't say for now, as I don't want to influence people, and even I am not 100% which one would be considered canonical, although I do have one in mind. Maybe I'll share my opinion after they've all been released ; )
Just to make sure. Impregnation only or do you actually want to show pregnancy scenes? Standing CGs?Mostly towards the end, at least for the main characters. Some side characters get impregnated a bit earlier in game, although not at the beginning.
Some of us like and actively seek out anal-only content.Would be quite boring if it would stay at anal only for rose until endings only ngl.
Thats totally fine.Some of us like and actively seek out anal-only content.
i love it when you have different possible outcomes, even tho its unlogical.From what I’ve gathered based on what Master N_taii has said, the main girls won’t cross the final line or do anything completely irreversible until the story reaches the branching point that leads to the two NTR endings, the happy ending, and the revenge ending. In other words, everything that happens before that point serves as buildup to those three possible outcomes. Unfortunately, there won’t be a True Ending this time.
It’s also important to understand that N_taii is first and foremost a creator who genuinely enjoys NTR stories, especially ones where the NTR element is unavoidable. That is the heart of his storytelling style. The happy ending usually exists more as a gift to fans who prefer closure or redemption, but the main focus of his works remains on the emotional and psychological weight of NTR itself.
Because of this, it’s completely natural to notice some inconsistencies in the happy endings, like in HC2, and possibly in HC3 as well. When the narrative is built primarily around NTR, trying to wrap it up with a happy resolution can feel contradictory or forced. But that’s part of the charm of this kind of story. It’s not meant to be perfectly logical, but to make players feel strong and conflicting emotions.
That’s what makes N_taii’s works so memorable. They mix love, guilt, lust, and regret in a way that makes you feel both anger and fascination at the same time. It’s painful, but that pain is what makes the experience powerful.
After all, no one would ever enjoy losing the person they love in real life. It would cause permanent emotional scars. But in fiction, that same suffering becomes a form of catharsis, a safe way to explore jealousy, loss, and obsession without real consequences. That’s the real strength of N_taii’s writing.
if you found the title of the game you described, i would be happy to hear it.As a tester and reviewer who has actually played both Dyed in White and similar titles, I can confirm that it’s true—especially in Dyed in White, the game forces you to go through the NTR routes before you can unlock the so-called “happy ending.” Honestly, it’s frustrating. Unlike Henteria Chronicles 2, where the MC can still have sex scenes with Celis and other women, most other NTR games completely remove any sexual content from the “pure love” routes. That makes no sense to me. It’s as if making love to someone who genuinely loves you back is somehow wrong.
I’ve heard that some NTR creators actually dislike anything “vanilla.” Maybe they went through bad love experiences themselves, or maybe they’ve never been in a relationship at all. But one thing’s certain—they almost never include erotic scenes in happy endings, which is a shame. Of course, I get that the main appeal of NTR games is the NTR content, but still…
Personally, I prefer hybrid stories. For example, I really wish the creator of Monica Newlywed had gone further with the NTR aspect, letting the MC “reverse-NTR” Monica further by seducing other heroines— instead of seeing them being coerced by other men like it happen in the game. In the end, the previously cuckolded MC would cuckold his girlfriend, while her friends who love him get NTR’d too. It would have been better if a harem was possible, especially after Monia losed her virginity to a random guy after she was raped. She could appologize to the MC and let him beat the rapist lol.
What I truly dislike are MCs who are powerless losers—it just feels like the story is screaming “I deserve this misery.” I read a lot of NTR manga and manhwa; some are amazing, others downplay the weight of cheating by letting the MC sleep around freely, as if it carries no emotional consequence. I prefer when the women’s reactions matter—whether they accept being part of a harem or reject it, depending on their personalities.
Some games, anime, and manhwa really stand out because of that emotional depth, and I genuinely think Henteria Chronicles is one of those rare gems. That’s why I’m forever thankful to N_Taii for creating such an impactful series.
There’s also one excellent NTR game I can’t remember the title of, but I’d love to find it again. It’s set in a dystopian world where the MC and his childhood friend secretly love each other. A rich young man, whose powerful parents bought the ruined company of the student council president’s family, takes her as his slave. Eventually, he sets his eyes on the MC’s childhood friend, who’s so in love with the MC that he has to make a deal: if the MC wins a contest, he’ll get his dream job—but if he loses, the noble gets his girlfriend as a maid.
At first, the MC refuses, but his childhood friend convinces him to accept. Then you have to talk to other students and the noble to negotiate contest conditions—choosing judges, deciding the themes, etc.—but most of the judges and teachers are under the noble’s influence, making it hard to win.
What made it special is that another girl who loves the MC can help him, and he can even flirt with her. Meanwhile, his childhood friend is so devoted that she accepts shady “requests” from classmates just to learn who the MC loves, though they deceive her to corrupt her. The developer even stated it would be extremely hard to reach the good ending.
In one of the endings, even after she betrays the MC, there’s this unforgettable scene where he’s about to leave town by train. She stops him, tearfully apologizes, and begs him to let her come with him despite not being “pure” anymore—and he accepts. It’s bittersweet but genuinely touching.
I remember finding the game while searching for NTR Classroom. It also takes place in a school setting. If anyone knows the title, I’d love to hear it.
Yes, they each have their own reasons, but when I replayed Henteria Chronicles 3 from the beginning several times (after losing my saves), it became clear to me that all the women are in love with the MC—even if they never openly admit it since he’s officially with Rose. Cyanna, for example, clearly loves him deeply and sees him as more than just a brother figure.
I’d love if we could unlock an ending with her, because seeing her with that jerk really bothers me, haha. But the worst offender is the guy involved with Helen. I read somewhere that in the newer updates, she even lets him assault other women while knowing it’s wrong? Maybe I misunderstood, but her behavior has become really disappointing. I’m curious which of them will end up being the least forgivable.
In any case, all of them are so sexually sensitive and overcharged that they end up surrendering to pleasure and forgetting their pain entirely.
N_Taii doesn't really like hurting the girls in the revenge endings in his games (in HC2 the worst they go through is slave sex which isn't really a that much different from what they were already doing), the thing that i found unsatisfying was that in HC2 revenge ending the it didn't feel like Noah was taking revenge as he became a completely different careacter, i hope that Leto will still be mostly the same man in the revenge ending or if he changes its not so drastic that he becomes super evil as then the revenge wont feel like the characters are getting what they deserve.i hope (i know) we have this in this game too (and i truly hope, N_taii if you see my comment, let there be hell for the girls and villians in the revenge ending, they should get punished severely, even in happy end)
by punished, i meant emotionally, like they be broken and REALLY understand what they've done. and i agree with the rest, hope for peak revenge and happy endings.N_Taii doesn't really like hurting the girls in the revenge endings in his games (in HC2 the worst they go through is slave sex which isn't really a that much different from what they were already doing), the thing that i found unsatisfying was that in HC2 revenge ending the it didn't feel like Noah was taking revenge as he became a completely different careacter, i hope that Leto will still be mostly the same man in the revenge ending or if he changes its not so drastic that he becomes super evil as then the revenge wont feel like the characters are getting what they deserve.
I agree.N_Taii doesn't really like hurting the girls in the revenge endings in his games (in HC2 the worst they go through is slave sex which isn't really a that much different from what they were already doing), the thing that i found unsatisfying was that in HC2 revenge ending the it didn't feel like Noah was taking revenge as he became a completely different careacter, i hope that Leto will still be mostly the same man in the revenge ending or if he changes its not so drastic that he becomes super evil as then the revenge wont feel like the characters are getting what they deserve.
kinks and tastes expand like colors, its about how much a game offers to you, there are many plain ntr or vanilla games without any emotional impact, and there are games like hc, that the most erotic scene you get is a moving pixel on another moving pixel, but you can really feel the pain, because of the writing.Wow, this was truly an unforgettable experience after spending 3 days playing up to the current update.
I haven't played 1 and 2, so I probably don't fully understand, but I must say that after reading from page 360 up to the present, I was a bit confused. What I see is that people seem to be expressing their dislike for the NTR element in an NTR game, and the characters to become gradually corrupted, in a game that has the three letters NTR boldly stamped in red in its title. I feel like I am the only one who wants to see the characters fall LOL.
I was a bit naive to think that everyone who plays this game must necessarily enjoy NTR (I thought that no matter which ending you aim for, you have to see the NTR, so you shouldn't dislike it). Perhaps I should look at things from more perspectives instead of confused.kinks and tastes expand like colors, its about how much a game offers to you, there are many plain ntr or vanilla games without any emotional impact, and there are games like hc, that the most erotic scene you get is a moving pixel on another moving pixel, but you can really feel the pain, because of the writing.
when a game can have multiple outcomes and different choices, you have more freedom on what ending you want to choose, or rather, you just want to see what happes «if» i went on another path.
the more freedom you have, the more people with different opinions play your game.
and before you come and say «but you get cucked throughout the game and that can't be changed nor it can be avoided, i know and thats why i only play the endings, thats too much pain for me to handle and i can't read it from start to finish, i only read summary xD. many people play avoidable ntr games because they want a challenge and risk of losing, some just want to see all the ntrs and dont care about anything else, some like to feel the pain and have the option to revenge at the end, some want redemption. so, its not that strange to see these kind of messages, its about tastes, and tastes expand like colors and have different shades.
if you really hate ntr, you wouldn't play this game at all you know? so the majority of people in this thread enjoy or at least can tolerate ntr to some extent, so your not completely wrong, but i believe there is more to it than some think there is, like the meme «is ntr avoidable» that many people laugh to is something that many people do enjoy about in an eroge game.im the type who can tolerate it if i have the option to revenge,redemption or at least avoid it sometimes you know? it can be strange but i like the satisfaction of getting revenge on those who betrayed you and this game does it well, another game which is one of my favorites is «My...» that recently got an update, you can avoid the ntr and it does it so well that you really want to focus, just to avoid the tragedies.I was a bit naive to think that everyone who plays this game must necessarily enjoy NTR (I thought that no matter which ending you aim for, you have to see the NTR, so you shouldn't dislike it). Perhaps I should look at things from more perspectives instead of confused.