Uff, no mater what route i take, i cant help but to feel sorry for Lucy ^^ honestly, this game has some of the more convincing chars and developement.
Yeah, this is one of those choices that makes me a little annoyed with the author.
Like, no matter who I pick, I feel guilty about the girl I didn't pick.
Lucy is vulnerable and hurt at the moment you have to choose if it's her or Charlotte. And rejecting her feels a bit an ass move in that moment.
But Charlotte's situation is no better, she is also vulnerable, broken and scared. But in her case, MC at least remains a bodyguard and a friend, and she doesn't even think of something more. For Lucy, the rejection is very painful. She once again feels like a second-class compared to Charlotte.