- Oct 17, 2020
- 601
- 7,370
View attachment 1927893
You must be registered to see the links
PREVIEW IMAGES
Emma returns to college.
Charlotte sleeps.
Lucy receives an early morning call.
- Thread starter monroe
- Start date
- Nov 1, 2017
- 4,704
- 10,050
I have to be honest with myself. I've been following Lucy's path and she's my favorite girl but if Charlotte ever gets any content I'm replaying the game from the beginning and telling Lucy I'm gay.
If only that were an option, but even if you could, Lucy would find out the truth and you'd start a whole new war in the game, could be interesting though.
- Nov 14, 2017
- 67,431
- 34,039
no it wouldn't.
Seriously though, if we can't have Charlotte and Lucy side by side then at least allow us to introduce Lucy to the guy in the bar so she can at least have someone to make her happy even if it isn't the main character. Seeing her sad just makes the game that much more difficult. Also given how caring the MC seems to be towards them all it seems like hurting any of them is not something that he plans to do.
- Jan 3, 2018
- 4,915
- 10,323
If 4 women love him & he only loves 1 of them, 3 of them are going to be hurt, in some way.
It's not his intention, but it's an inevitable outcome.
What matters, is how you handle them being hurt.
Each of Emma, Lucy & Suzi can take pleasure in seeing Charlotte happy.
Hopefully they can put aside the personal feeling of rejection (if that strong) for the pleasure of that.
The problem is though, he doesn't just love one, but he chooses to ignore his feelings for others because of who or how he is.
See I don't think of it as an inevitable outcome, if anyone else was in his position surely they'd try to share the happiness around.
I'm just going to wait until the story is complete and see how this whole dynamic plays out.
- Jan 3, 2018
- 4,915
- 10,323
He does in my game, romantically.
My MC is only interested in Charlotte.
Cares for Emma like a daughter.
Doesn't love Suzi, but cares about her because of who/how he is, also because of what she means to Charlotte & Emma.
Doesn't love Lucy, rejected her romantic advances, but cares about her.
Ha ha ha, yeah & see how long you stay in a relationship when you tell your partner she's not enough to satisfy you, so she should share you with her sister & daughters.
Last edited:
At no point did I mention one woman wouldn't be enough, but in this game, I'm playing a caring guy and I see it as the guy feels like shit because he can see how upset Lucy is, hurting her doesn't sit well with him and it doesn't with me either, anyone with half a heart would do whatever they could to bring Lucy some happiness, so in that respect, I think the future of this game will likely have some cheating aspects with Lucy behind Charlotte's back.
- Jan 3, 2018
- 4,915
- 10,323
What?
You care about upsetting her, so you'll fuck her behind her sister's back? As a bit on the side?
Wow!
Don't mind upsetting her sister, then? Charlotte trusting the MC is huge. The damage to their relationship & her relationship with her sister would be massive.
Don't mind how the daughters will react to that, or how it will damage their relationship with their Aunt?
I'm not seeing how caring about Lucy's feelings equates to that conclusion.
Her being hurt is not sitting well, sure. But giving her a pity fuck is not going to make it any better.
Cheating on her sister with her is not going to make it any better. It's just going to make her feel justifiably guilty.
Last edited:
Your words not mine, I never once mentioned that I would cheat behind someone's back, I said I could see the future of this game having cheating aspects with Lucy behind Charlotte's back, maybe even with other girls.
You have your views on this game, whatever they might be, and everyone else has theirs, but as you put it, despite seeing how heartbroken Lucy was when MC rejected her you would rather her be that upset and consider leaving her family (her sister behind) because she can't bear to see the man she clearly has feelings for being with her sister Charlotte.
Either way, this conversation is going nowhere, it's just devolved into each one of us throwing about opinions which may never even happen. Time will tell what this game turns into.
You have your views on this game, whatever they might be, and everyone else has theirs, but as you put it, despite seeing how heartbroken Lucy was when MC rejected her you would rather her be that upset and consider leaving her family (her sister behind) because she can't bear to see the man she clearly has feelings for being with her sister Charlotte.
Either way, this conversation is going nowhere, it's just devolved into each one of us throwing about opinions which may never even happen. Time will tell what this game turns into.
- Jan 3, 2018
- 4,915
- 10,323
When you talked about "wanting to share the happiness around", you were referring to the source of that happiness as being the MC & then you suggested that adding cheating will supply Lucy with some happiness.
Having just said that you "will do whatever it takes to bring her some happiness." The implication is clear.
You used your MC's "caring guy" persona as reasoning for why you can see cheating in the game's future.
Cheating is not caring for anything but your own gratification.
"I know you're damaged & trusting me was a huge thing, but I only fucked your sister & betrayed that trust because I'm a nice guy & didn't want to hurt her."
Yeah, that's gonna work out well.
Well, mine is based on how the characters and the story have been set-up.You have your views on this game, whatever they might be, and everyone else has theirs, but as you put it, despite seeing how heartbroken Lucy was when MC rejected her you would rather her be that upset and consider leaving her family (her sister behind) because she can't bear to see the man she clearly has feelings for being with her sister Charlotte.
Either way, this conversation is going nowhere, it's just devolved into each one of us throwing about opinions which may never even happen. Time will tell what this game turns into.
Yours seems to be edging closer to a wish list scenario, or turning the MC into a disloyal, dishonest cheat, which is completely out of character.
You say you do not want to hurt Lucy, then propose something particularly hurtful to her family &, by extension, to her
She'll get over being rejected by the MC. She's perfectly capable of meeting someone.
She won't get over being rejected by her sister and her nieces, losing her family & having them lose trust in her.
Not to mention the guilt she'd then carry, for having played a part in ruining her sister's happiness.
If you do not want to hurt Lucy by rejecting her, then perhaps commit to being with her exclusively & make her feel truly special.
Fucking her behind her sister's back is absolutely not the answer.
Last edited:
- Oct 17, 2020
- 601
- 7,370
Lucy will never accept to come second in the life of the man she loves, not after she has been through this all her life, and really by doing that you destroying your relationship with the two sisters. Charlotte will not accept to be with a man who cheating on her with her sister, nor will Lucy accept to be with MC While he is in a relationship with her sisterYour words not mine, I never once mentioned that I would cheat behind someone's back, I said I could see the future of this game having cheating aspects with Lucy behind Charlotte's back, maybe even with other girls.
You have your views on this game, whatever they might be, and everyone else has theirs, but as you put it, despite seeing how heartbroken Lucy was when MC rejected her you would rather her be that upset and consider leaving her family (her sister behind) because she can't bear to see the man she clearly has feelings for being with her sister Charlotte.
Either way, this conversation is going nowhere, it's just devolved into each one of us throwing about opinions which may never even happen. Time will tell what this game turns into.
Lucy alone is enough for MC, and Charlotte is much more than enough, they are both amazing women and the best in their field so make your choice Because you can't have both
I prefer Charlotte, the Queen and Angel of Hillside, but Lucy is also a great woman, and I respect her, and I think she deserves to be with a man loves her and makes her feel special.
- Nov 11, 2020
- 1,694
- 3,411
I agree, I don't think cheating on Charlotte with Lucy, after having rejected her, will cheer up her.When you talked about "wanting to share the happiness around", you were referring to the source of that happiness as being the MC & then you suggested that adding cheating will supply Lucy with some happiness.
Having just said that you "will do whatever it takes to bring her some happiness." The implication is clear.
You used your MC's "caring guy" persona as reasoning for why you can see cheating in the game's future.
Cheating is not caring for anything but your own gratification.
"I know you're damaged & trusting me was a huge thing, but I only fucked your sister & betrayed that trust because I'm a nice guy & didn't want to hurt her."
Yeah, that's gonna work out well.
Well, mine is based on how the characters and the story have been set-up.
Yours seems to be edging closer to a wish list scenario, or turning the MC into a disloyal, dishonest cheat, which is completely out of character.
You say you do not want to hurt Lucy, then propose something particularly hurtful to her family &, by extension, to her
She'll get over being rejected by the MC. She's perfectly capable of meeting someone.
She won't get over being rejected by her sister and her nieces, losing her family & having them lose trust in her.
Not to mention the guilt she'd then carry, for having played a part in ruining her sister's happiness.
If you do not want to hurt Lucy by rejecting her, then perhaps commit to being with her exclusively & make her feel truly special.
Fucking her behind her sister's back is absolutely not the answer.
She has always fell like living in the shadow of her sister. And surly that sometimes, she will be jealous of Charlotte. But she also clearly love her sister. And she very well know the trusted issues Charlotte has with men.
So I really don't see Lucy accepting to cheat on her sister.
Anyway, I will never have to do that, as I'm on Lucy route.
I must admit I can't resist when I learn how she was always betrayed by men that only used her to approach her sister.
I want to play the good guy. And prove her a man can love her for what she is. Anyway she's clever, funny, and beautiful. Not the "perfect beauty" of a top model, but the real beauty of a real woman.
And I don't have plan to cheat on her.
I already turn down Kayla.
Now, I hope there is a way to being a true friend of Charlotte, but not in a romantic way. And that she will find someone faithful to her.
I will care of Suzy, like a daughter, not a LI.
Same with Emma. But I must admit that more than a few time, I did want to slap her and shoot "WAKE UP!!!" at her. I know she has the role of the naive girl. But here, sorry to say, it's borderline with abyssal stupidity!
- Oct 17, 2020
- 601
- 7,370
- Jan 3, 2018
- 4,915
- 10,323
Yep, quite agree.
But, to be fair, her lack of social skills & awareness is probably not helped by the situation with Charlotte. You can see her being particularly protective of Emma, so sheltering her.
That does not excuse her lack of critical thinking & perception.
But, maybe being sheltered is why she's still immature & unaware.
Last edited:
- Jun 2, 2017
- 2,468
- 7,407
I think a lot of people here do not understand the capacity for humans to ignore or overlook "red flags", "warning signs", and all of that when they are really into someone. Particularly if they are young and it is the first "love" they have had.
I have seen both guys and girls in that situation straight up BLIND to the problems. They downplay, they rationalize, they do whatever to not see the bad.
Later on, they tend to be really mad at themselves for ignoring it but they only get there after it has all gone wrong. Then it is 50/50 on how they treat the people that tried to warn them. Half realize how good that person was and half can never forgive them because they would have to admit how bad their own part was in being blind.
Again I have seen it in both men and women but to be fair, many more men just wanted sex and it wasn't a big emotional thing so it had close to no impact whereas the women tend to be deeply hurt by it. So on balance it is a worse problem for women.
PEACE
(Yes this was all Emma based again)
I have seen both guys and girls in that situation straight up BLIND to the problems. They downplay, they rationalize, they do whatever to not see the bad.
Later on, they tend to be really mad at themselves for ignoring it but they only get there after it has all gone wrong. Then it is 50/50 on how they treat the people that tried to warn them. Half realize how good that person was and half can never forgive them because they would have to admit how bad their own part was in being blind.
Again I have seen it in both men and women but to be fair, many more men just wanted sex and it wasn't a big emotional thing so it had close to no impact whereas the women tend to be deeply hurt by it. So on balance it is a worse problem for women.
PEACE
(Yes this was all Emma based again)
Since there is no harem path, I have 4 (although it appears I have to back up a few updates). One for each of them. If I had tot choose only one it would be Charlotte by a mile. Fortunately I have access to parallel realities and can choose each of them. Yes, on Emma's path, I don't consider her as anything other than an adult. I don't plan on taking advantage of her inexperience, but if she decides she has stopped seeing me as a surrogate father, why would I not treat her as an adult?
To be honest, I don't see a harem path possible at this point.
To be honest, I don't see a harem path possible at this point.