I too fall into the Lucy camp but to be fair it is kind of like picking the valedictorian at summer school. The Lloyd family is maladjusted and Lucy is kind of like the glue that keeps all the broken pieces together. I do think that we will eventually see her bad side. Everybody has one. I think that on the path where MC picks Charlotte instead of her, she might break. Even though she is used to it at this point, it's going to hurt her since it keeps happening over and over. She was very open, honest, and brave in telling the MC that she had feelings for him. Didn't even hide it from the other girls. It is as if she is the only one who isn't ashamed of her own feelings. I did think she was a little annoying about it in the beginning and I don't think that I really fell in love with her until she protected Charli from that guy in the bathroom and got a slap for it. I've come around to thinking that all of the other three girls have one very redeeming virtue (Suzi is brave, Emma is compassionate, Charlie is devoted) but in the Llloyd family, Lucy has all of them. She's the one they all go to whenever there is a problem and she fixes it. That can be very taxing when you have the role in a family (I know this from experience) but she bears it with grace. I think that the thing that attracts the MC to Lucy in the Lucy path is that he can tell right away that she would be a good partner. That she would be ready and willing to have a mature, committed, and stable relationship right off the bat. The other girls really don't offer that prospect. Not to say that the others won't eventually come around to being good partners, but when it comes to Lucy there is much less assembly required.