Yeah the MC in the story has a fatherly personality. That's the best adjective I could come up with. I don't really see him being in a relationship with someone who's just 18 and acts like she's 12. I can see him being with either Charlotte or her sister. But definitely neither of the daughters or even the other model really.
I almost agree with you. The only problem I see in a relationship with Lucy would be, that Charlotte would be jealous and question herself how it can be that after all these years she can trust a man again and still remains lonely, because he prefers her more open-hearted sister and on the other hand she would be happy for her sister that she found someone but the disappointment of being rejected by MC would of course remain in Charlotte.
I see Lucy with her open manner, easier to get to know men than her sister Charlotte who first has to build trust in a man, which can take months and years. MC is the protector of her daughter and yet she still needs time to trust him completely and then to develop feelings for him. I see MC with Charlotte, because for me they belong together personally. And I don't think that every man who is interested in Lucy has bad intentions to hurt her feelings and who knows maybe Steve would be someone for Lucy, only of course if he has nothing to do with Emma's stalker thing.
I can see him with the older sister. She's old enough, independent enough, and about to get saved. That might be enough to shift her view of the MC, and she's more than aggressive enough to tackle him and make her interest known. It would make one hell of a scene...
It would be one hell of a scene, but most of the time when I see Suzi in the game and with her friend Hannah, who she gets advice from, it seems to me that Suzi and Hannah could be more than just friends in the future. I see them together as a lovely couple. Maybe Suzi and Hannah doesn't need a man to be happy.
But the nice thing about this conversations between us, is that everyone can have a different opinion and it is interesting to read what someone else thinks and would decide. Therefore there is no right or wrong in such decisions.