hottarod
Very good!
Once the FAQ became so huge, I reorganized it so that it could be easily split up. Especially the checklist and the Hotshots answers, and now the Guess Who descriptions.
I kept it together for ease of posting, but everyone should edit it to make it as useful as possible.
I don't find the game unplayable without it. By playing the game, things will usually just happen. Finding these things gives you a sense of excitement which is part of what makes this a great game. However, I doubt I'd have figured out how to get Yumiko's Easter egg without help from the people on this thread.
I don't think it's cheating to use it. You're just asking for help and that's not wrong. However, you do lose a sense of discovery so that's why there is a spoiler alert for everything there.
I started making my FAQ because of Bantry's request. It was just a little 20 question list of all the questions we had to answer over and over about how to fuck Ivy or whatever. Then Bantry suggested it could be as close to a walkthrough as we can get for this game. That's when I reorganized it and tried to answer any question that might come up. Now it's over 150 questions and ready to answer many more for 1.9.
I did it just to help the players, and I hope it still does.