Nocdub

Newbie
Nov 28, 2018
57
44
That is a common problem in lewd games. When you want to play a smut game, you don't want intrincate game systems, lenghty politics dialogs, difficult combats, or excessive and long grindin, you want to enjoy the characters and first and foremost, the sex, Legend of Queen Opala, for example has some of this problems, hours of story, quests and going around without not knowing well what to do for a quick sex art cg (top notch quality, but too little, too short).

This game is accursed with the same malady. There's tons of text, tons of grind-quest, you have a scene with McGonagall, then she practically begs you to fuck her during the game, and you have no chance on foing so. Hours of content, hours of text....for mostly nothing. I couldn't believe when after...6 hours? I FINALLY had a blowjob scene with ginny. (Which also was super annoying to play since the game has this pauses between dialogue bubbles and it doesn't let you read and advance at your own rhythm, because the looped animation has to loop 200000 times before you can read the next dialogue, and that's SUPER FRUSTRATING. is that, or the super accelerated auto skip. That should be adressed too)
I was rooting for Daphne, but the game is, like it has been called in this thread before, the most blueball experience I had with porn games. It's like it doesn't have the amount of sex art needed for even an early alpha, and the creator just stretched the narrative/quest parts so he could keep charging the patreons for the updates.

Innocent Witches can be one of the greatest porn games. It has a fantastic art style, it has a beloved fantasy universe, and it's not a "1st person DAZ render sex game visual novel" that overpopulates this genre, it's unique. But right now is basically trash due to 4 issues.

-This game needs content. Sex content. Tons of it. Badly. More scenes. More characters to fuck or to have a casual encounter with
-It also needs to let you read at your own pace, during sex animations, if I click after I watch the loop a couple of times, it means I want to advance, not that I want to see the loop 20 more times.
-Third issue is language: I understand that the author/s are from Russia, but some things got super weird and barely understandable in the translation, that, mixed with some bugs, make the game sort of confusing to play in certain parts.
-4 Due to lack of content, you find yourself in lots of situation when the dialogue suggests there's a sex chance here, then it's a lie, there's none, either there's a blueballing dialogue that goes nowhere, either there's a "you died" situation, (like with the mermaid, if we can't fuck her because she drowns us, and we have her bra, let us see her tits, and/or let her suck us off, this is a porn parody game! it should be exploring all the sex opportunities the script throws to the player, not leave them hanging like that!)
 

Oriandu

Engaged Member
Sep 1, 2017
2,457
4,678
So, I've played around two hours and I'm enjoying the game so far, but I don't think I'm nearly 10% of the game completed, it's just so much text. So I just wanted to know beforehand, why does this game has such a low score here?
It has a low score because it's a mess. It's been around for nearly four years and it has less sexual content in it than many projects do in its first release. It has multiple quest lines in it that are poorly explained and expects the player to be able to figure things out on little to no instruction. It also assumes a certain level of knowledge on Harry Potter and then doesn't bother to explain things to people more interested in the art style than the fiction it's parodying.
 
  • Like
Reactions: George_Nos

JRZ17

Member
Dec 5, 2017
215
167
For those of you that are new to this game. Since couple of updates back the ship has a new captain at the helm Joe Banks. Since his arrival the game moves in a positive direction. So be a bit more patient with the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Oghmios1337

Doomsatan666

New Member
Feb 15, 2020
8
7
For those of you that are new to this game. Since couple of updates back the ship has a new captain at the helm Joe Banks. Since his arrival the game moves in a positive direction. So be a bit more patient with the game.
Will he retouch the game up to this point? I mean there would (imo) be huge imbalance if the first several hours of gameplay are like it is now and then suddenly satanic amount of smut appears.
 

anubis1970

Engaged Member
Mar 1, 2018
2,107
2,344
Will he retouch the game up to this point? I mean there would (imo) be huge imbalance if the first several hours of gameplay are like it is now and then suddenly satanic amount of smut appears.
From what I understand, Joe and the current team will be going back and editing the early chapters to condense the massive walls of text you have to wade through, but first they're concentrating on getting some decent content into the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Oghmios1337

candiddelicious

New Member
May 25, 2020
1
0
I agree that the game needs to have MUCH less grinding side quests and MORE sex scenes, and not too many teases and no context at all... I'm honestly disappointed.

The artwork is superb, I think it's wasted potential to just have 1-2 H-scenes and a lot of teasing.

I like the little background characters where you can see someone like Merula from the Hogwarts Mystery app game, characters like Babydoll of Sucker Punch, and many others. I thought this was a lot of fun. I thought they could be interacted with a bit more.

Also I think the environment should be larger or more interactable. Repeating the same rooms for hours with nothing new or interesting gets boring quickly, because we have to do the same stuff a lot.

On Act I, after trying Daphne's mini game for about 30-35 times, and guessing almost %90 of her lingerie correct, I gave up because it was too repetitive and not worth it. Also even though I was going by walkthrough and giving the exact answers to her expressions, it kept saying I was wrong and I lost my strike. I thought I'm not going to bother anymore. (Small edit: She sometimes started giving 2 different expressions to 1 guess, and I didn't know what to do at this point. I started answering with the second expression, she said wrong. I started answering with the first one, she still said wrong.)

Again on Act I; I also had to give up Mermaid’s Treasure quest because (according to the walkthrough) after summoning Snape informally ("look what I found"), nothing could be done with McGonagall. I tried weekdays, weekends, official, informal mails, every hour. Nope, she doesn't give any extra answers, there is nothing in her dialogue. I thought I'm not her fan anyway and gave up. Maybe it could work on another arc now, I don't know.

Sonya has absolutely no point at all. Buying clothes for Sonya does nothing. Basically, Sonya does nothing, at least so far. Maybe these could be improved. Also I wish I could stop her from saying things like "Nya <3"... I thought she was going to be a guide and help out whenever we were lost during a quest, but she did nothing.

One last thing: The walkthrough (The one that's a google document; sorry can't post links since I'm a new member) isn't exactly a walkthrough :/ I mean at this point, the book in the upper right corner was more of a walkthrough than this document. Saying things like "this does something" isn't a help to people who are lost. Step by step explanations were better, but I still didn't understand why some things didn't work even though I was following everything.
The quest order in this document is very very messy too, I didn't know I was on Act I of the walkthrough until I put on the Diadem.

I know that the game is still developing, but I wanted to share my thoughts after playing it for a couple of days. Now I'm on Act II.

So far I like it, but definitely, 100% needs more H-scenes and much less grind quests.


Edit: Question!
I lost the walkthrough where there was a dark background, the instructions were like the google document's but some things like Daphne's expressions during her mini game, were explained by screenshots. I think I found it here on this forum, but I can't find it again. Does anybody have that walkthrough? Thanks.
 
Last edited:

arkhanan

Newbie
Mar 30, 2019
16
3
That is a common problem in lewd games. When you want to play a smut game, you don't want intrincate game systems, lenghty politics dialogs, difficult combats, or excessive and long grindin, you want to enjoy the characters and first and foremost, the sex, Legend of Queen Opala, for example has some of this problems, hours of story, quests and going around without not knowing well what to do for a quick sex art cg (top notch quality, but too little, too short).

This game is accursed with the same malady. There's tons of text, tons of grind-quest, you have a scene with McGonagall, then she practically begs you to fuck her during the game, and you have no chance on foing so. Hours of content, hours of text....for mostly nothing. I couldn't believe when after...6 hours? I FINALLY had a blowjob scene with ginny. (Which also was super annoying to play since the game has this pauses between dialogue bubbles and it doesn't let you read and advance at your own rhythm, because the looped animation has to loop 200000 times before you can read the next dialogue, and that's SUPER FRUSTRATING. is that, or the super accelerated auto skip. That should be adressed too)
I was rooting for Daphne, but the game is, like it has been called in this thread before, the most blueball experience I had with porn games. It's like it doesn't have the amount of sex art needed for even an early alpha, and the creator just stretched the narrative/quest parts so he could keep charging the patreons for the updates.

Innocent Witches can be one of the greatest porn games. It has a fantastic art style, it has a beloved fantasy universe, and it's not a "1st person DAZ render sex game visual novel" that overpopulates this genre, it's unique. But right now is basically trash due to 4 issues.

-This game needs content. Sex content. Tons of it. Badly. More scenes. More characters to fuck or to have a casual encounter with
-It also needs to let you read at your own pace, during sex animations, if I click after I watch the loop a couple of times, it means I want to advance, not that I want to see the loop 20 more times.
-Third issue is language: I understand that the author/s are from Russia, but some things got super weird and barely understandable in the translation, that, mixed with some bugs, make the game sort of confusing to play in certain parts.
-4 Due to lack of content, you find yourself in lots of situation when the dialogue suggests there's a sex chance here, then it's a lie, there's none, either there's a blueballing dialogue that goes nowhere, either there's a "you died" situation, (like with the mermaid, if we can't fuck her because she drowns us, and we have her bra, let us see her tits, and/or let her suck us off, this is a porn parody game! it should be exploring all the sex opportunities the script throws to the player, not leave them hanging like that!)
don't exsists fuck scene that is the big problem, no a sinlge cc fuking somebody
 

Delambo

Newbie
Jan 10, 2018
99
87
I love the art and detail, the grind is hard to motivate yourself through, the text is... copious.

Joe is right that Arkhan is wrong when he says there is NOT a single cc fucking somebody. There IS a single cc fucking somebody.


Anyone got a timeline on the update going on Mega?
 

Keyra

Newbie
Feb 18, 2019
26
8
If somebody want to do manipulation/minigame,just put this in your game folder.Makes it easier :3
 

Oriandu

Engaged Member
Sep 1, 2017
2,457
4,678
Joe Underpants swoops in to smack down the fake news. Spicy!
Yeah, smack down the fake news... with sex with a side character few people care about, that happened a looooong time ago, and with a scene that isn't actually sex and is more or less just the same thing repeated four times. So spicy. So, so spicy. So spicy it's a green bell pepper.
 

Vanko1984

Newbie
Jan 4, 2020
57
144
I wouldn't see a problem with veeeery long non-spicy/barely-spicy content, would it be justified by gradual corruption that is shown, moreover, I would wholeheartedly support it. It takes soooo long to get from Minerva sex to Jinny blow, and it wouldn't be so frustrating, would there be mini-scenes showing step-by-step changing heroines, instead of confrontation after confrontation only to get their journals in the end of act 2 and find out all of them are already wishing for MC to get in their wet panties.
 
Apr 10, 2020
228
266
These are all fair points and I share the pain.

But I distinguish between this game, where I sense the developers are trying (especially more recently), and a game like Library Story, where I feel like I am being played.

I still think this is a diamond in the rough. It has a lot of quality and I think it will get there. I would like to encourage the devs to get there faster, but I would also like to encourage them not to get discouraged.
 
3.00 star(s) 322 Votes