As much as John may perceive Melissa as "the one who got away"... from all the information we have, ultimately it was just a short fling, he shouldn't expect anything.It already happened in Melissa's dream, and the attraction is there... Now the reality can come... But there is little chance of that, despite the fact that there are several beautiful MILFs in the game, the author does not do this, it would be too beautiful... And anyway, What right would John have to interfere in this? He left Melissa a thousand years ago, he has no say in what Melissa and MC do.
There's an interesting tidbit that when he looks like at Erynn he says "she looks like someone he knew when he was young" so he still has fond memories of that fling.
There's just something special about a girl who smiles with cum in her face!!!!
Btw, I misgifed the previous post.