You weren't even in the conversation, i have no idea what you quoted...Gonna have to play the devil...again (you make it far too easy)...
So everything in your mind is...maybe, maybe, maybe, no evidence, no proof...nothing shown blah blah blahh/....
But what I quoted...is set in stone and undeniable...despite what you keep professing to the contrary....
*shrugs*...so which is it? You cannot have one and not the other. It's all or nothing. So there is either no proof of either, (therefore you cannot make solid stone cold blanket statements)...or there is.
Everything points to no connection at all, the lack of memories of each other, Erynn saying they never talked, the fact that all their memories of each other goes back to one single moment and that absolutely nothing else ever comes up.
People saying they had this big connection are the ones doing extrapolations... "well Erynn could've been wrong", "i believe that she liked him more than that", how about you bring some "undeniable proof"?
You try to play nice and not do absolute statements and look what happens...Perhaps he is just giving his opinion? Not trying to make an absolute statement.
Many things are left purposefully vague in Intertwined.