It's almost certain John is the father. Mel talked about who was Erynn's father with flashbacks and even though we don't see his face, he has exact same tattoo of John's. Though, there is teeny tiny problem with it which is John's tattoo's are not consistent.
The tatoo problem maybe will be solved when the remake reaches John, i don't know why Nyx went with the old set of tatoos rather than the more up to date, but oh well...
It would be a huge asspull to make someone else Erynn's dad now.
People are almost sure his father is Navarro, though I have my doubts about it. Though, Navarro really looks like MC. So that can be possible. Btw, would not be perfect if Andres is his father. While Emily is pretty sure about Santiago, she was already dating Andres when she learnt she was pregnant and she assumed Santi is the father.
Navarro seems to fit the best, and Nyx said it's someone who we've met, not some random guy that will appear out of nowhere.
I do admit that Andres being actually the father would be a neat trick lol.
In the flashbacks Alexis' father is not in the picture. Adriana mentioned Alexis was staying with grandparents iirc, so there is a possibility that Layla and Alexis being half-sisters. Also if I am correct Zo is the husband of Adriana, if so as Zo is also being friends with Santiago Emily should have known Adriana more than just a roommate.
If it is Zo he was also a college student, so he can't attend to Alexis when Adriana has to study for exams, hence staying with the grandparents...
A couple of things about the girls, Adriana uses the surname Moore, while both Alexis and Layla use Monroe which must come from their dad, it's not absolute proof, but most likely the same guy made both of them... and he doesn't seem to favour/protect one kid over the the other.
Zo and Santiago did hang out when in college, but Emily says Adriana was a roommate that was never there... and she admits she mostly stayed at her family home and probably didn't party as much being already a mother.
I am not entirely sure about this but iirc, Iris' mother left or died while Iris was small and John raised her as a single dad. I don't think we'll ever see her mother.
Iris' mom seems a non topic, never brought up.
I don't think it will be made a topic... but oh well.
If it is i hope the exposition is done well, it might get awkward seeing Iris explaining to her ex(?)boyfriend about her mother despite the fact that they dated for 2 years.
Nyx joked about Elena being MC's half sister. Maybe she is hiding the truth behind the joke?
It would be in character for Santiago to knock her up and run... I don't think it will happen because Nyx is steering clear of incest, but it's not impossible.
Maybe she's Andres kid... wouldn't that be something?
.
Yeah, Nikki is just perfect in every way. She has very good relationship with both parents. Cara's relation with Mike is not the best but it's getting there.
Yeah score another point for her, no need to solve daddy issues lol.
With all these single moms... i wonder how many girls we can knock up by endgame? At least a basketball team right?
Don't you think Lexi or at least Layla would say "Stepdad" at some point if he wasn't their bio dad? They don't. They use the actual term dad.
I fall fairly strongly on the side that the guy that hangs around the Monroe house is the biological father of both girls, i just don't have absolute proof to make an affirmation, so i'm doing a bit of a devil's advocate.
