MrD812

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2021
1,529
2,263
I have no idea what you are saying or asking.

I showed it as the event was happening. (I could show you the frame before when MC runs away from Ethan).

I'm assuming you are calling me wrong, but your sentence makes no sense to me.

Either believe that Lexi ran after MC and comforted him or don't.
What i do or do not believe is irrelevant but a idea to consider.
MC wanted nothing to do with Erynn, what ever path is chosen.
Perfect sense for Lexi to go talk with MC.

He was straight up ghosting her, why not send Lexi?
Food for thought.
 

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
2,630
3,309
What i do or do not believe is irrelevant but a idea to consider.
MC wanted nothing to do with Erynn, what ever path is chosen.
Perfect sense for Lexi to go talk with MC.

He was straight up ghosting her, why not send Lexi?
Food for thought.
Erynn didn't even know she was being ghosted until after Lexi comforted him.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,314
18,831
What i do or do not believe is irrelevant but a idea to consider.
MC wanted nothing to do with Erynn, what ever path is chosen.
Perfect sense for Lexi to go talk with MC.

He was straight up ghosting her, why not send Lexi?
Food for thought.
I don't think that would make much sense tbh. Why would she try to go to his house and talk to his mother after if she was just gonna send Lexi , to check up on him. Unless she just told Lexi to make sure he is okay while she talks to Ethan , then that would make sense to me.
 

Justaphase

Well-Known Member
Donor
May 1, 2024
1,213
3,590
I don't think that would make much sense tbh. Why would she try to go to his house and talk to his mother after if she was just gonna send Lexi , to check up on him. Unless she just told Lexi to make sure he is okay while she talks to Ethan , then that would make sense to me.
I think that Lexi saw the MC sitting there all sad while on her way home and felt bad for him.
 

MrD812

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2021
1,529
2,263
Erynn didn't even know she was being ghosted until after Lexi comforted him.
MC wouldn't talk to her, what else could she do?

I don't think that would make much sense tbh. Why would she try to go to his house and talk to his mother after if she was just gonna send Lexi , to check up on him. Unless she just told Lexi to make sure he is okay while she talks to Ethan , then that would make sense to me.
She went there to talk with the MC First(Obviously).
How could she had known without trying First?
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,314
18,831
I think that Lexi saw the MC sitting there all sad while on her way home and felt bad for him.
me to im just saying if Erynn did send Lexi the only way the makes sense to me is if she wanted her to check if he is okay while she talks to Ethan. But personally just like you I think she just saw him sitting looking sad and wanted to talk to him because she is a nice person
 
  • Like
Reactions: Justaphase

MrD812

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2021
1,529
2,263
me to im just saying if Erynn did send Lexi the only way the makes sense to me is if she wanted her to check if he is okay while she talks to Ethan. But personally just like you I think she just saw him sitting looking sad and wanted to talk to him because she is a nice person
She didn't even talk with her at that event and lexi bails while she's dealing with Ethan.

screenshot0028.png
 

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
2,630
3,309
Yall gonna make me speedrun this bitch lolz.

ok like this scene so Im posting it here
Errxis.jpg

To clear up any confusion, if you ignore Alexis on the plane you won't see her talk with mc as a kid, as that reveal comes after Erryn confronts her for being with the mc. Otherwise, you'll see everything it just happens at two different points
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,314
18,831
She didn't even talk with her at that event and lexi bails while she's dealing with Ethan.

View attachment 4201636
well then with that screenshot your theory of Erynn sending Lexi cause the MC was ghosting her makes even less sense to me not that i thought it made any sense to begin with. But what I described was the only way it could make sense to me.

Edit : unless there is another conversation with Lexi and the MC as a kid im not aware of but the only one I know of is when she ran away and she comforted him and they kissed.
 

MrD812

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2021
1,529
2,263
well then with that screenshot your theory of Erynn sending Lexi cause the MC was being ghosting her makes even less sense to me not that i thought it made any sense to begin with. But what I described was the only way it could make sense to me.
I said, here's an Idea:

What i do or do not believe is irrelevant but a idea to consider.
MC wanted nothing to do with Erynn, what ever path is chosen.
Perfect sense for Lexi to go talk with MC.

He was straight up ghosting her, why not send Lexi?
Food for thought.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
14,314
18,831
I said, here's an Idea:
yeah if she did try to send Lexi after failing to talk to the MC would make sense to do something like that. But then the MC and Erynn would of probably started to talk again cause I bet Lexi would of cleared everything up as why wouldn't she. So it would go back to not making sense to me.
 

MrD812

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2021
1,529
2,263
yeah if she did try to send Lexi after failing to talk to the MC would make sense to do something like that. But then the MC and Erynn would of probably started to talk again cause I bet Lexi would of cleared everything up as why wouldn't she. So it would go back to not making sense to me.
Him not talking to her.. not even asking her 'why' she would laugh...was not very bright at all:

screenshot0086.png screenshot0087.png screenshot0088.png screenshot0089.png
 

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
2,482
5,169
I think that Lexi saw the MC sitting there all sad while on her way home and felt bad for him.
She didn't even talk with her at that event and lexi bails while she's dealing with Ethan.

View attachment 4201636
Yes, Alexis left on her own accord when Erynn and Ethan started fighting, no instructions from Erynn or anything else.

Did she set out to look for the MC?
We can't make any positive affirmations, but she doesn't run after the MC right after he runs away, she leaves non-chalantly after her friends start fighting with each other(it's hard to judge passage of time in something like this, but there has been quite the back and forth between Erynn and Ethan already... 2 min maybe?), to me she ran into him by chance and seeing him sad decided to say something nice, she wasn't going into his house to speak with him like Erynn tried later.

As the scene is portrayed, her main impulse for leaving is that Erynn and Ethan fighting is not something she enjoys being around, not thinking that the MC might be feeling bad and needs a friend right now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: valbitterb

duckydoodoo

Member
Nov 9, 2023
397
616
nah, you can't retcon your childhood. the damage is done, erynn can apologize but that trauma can not be walked back. all the theorizing is unimportant. there is only cucking your mom by knocking up her gf. nothing else matters anymore.
 

Adhdclassic

Engaged Member
Mar 10, 2024
3,834
5,756
My biggest question. I don't know about everyone else if I didn't like you I ain't dealing with you. Alexis didn't like Ethan and Erynn didn't either. So why the fuck did they deal with him for so many years. He was a dick and he never hid it.
 

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
2,630
3,309
Yes, Alexis left on her own accord when Erynn and Ethan started fighting, no instructions from Erynn or anything else.

Did she set out to look for the MC?
We can't make any positive affirmations, but she doesn't run after the MC right after he runs away, she leaves non-chalantly after her friends start fighting with each other(it's hard to judge passage of time in something like this, but there has been quite the back and forth between Erynn and Ethan already... 2 min maybe?), to me she ran into him by chance and seeing him sad decided to say something nice, she wasn't going into his house to speak with him like Erynn tried later.

As the scene is portrayed, her main impulse for leaving is that Erynn and Ethan fighting is not something she enjoys being around, not thinking that the MC might be feeling bad and needs a friend right now.
I think she saw a little kid that was clearly hurt and she went to console him as opposed to watching those two stand around and argue over dumb shit. Thats how I understood the scene. You're right she wasn't going into the house if he went in, but she likely went over to him as soon as she saw where he went.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LSC82

MilesEdgeworth

Engaged Member
Nov 8, 2021
2,630
3,309
My biggest question. I don't know about everyone else if I didn't like you I ain't dealing with you. Alexis didn't like Ethan and Erynn didn't either. So why the fuck did they deal with him for so many years. He was a dick and he never hid it.
Alexis's best friend was Erynn, so she was stuck hanging around Ethan as long as Erynn liked Ethan. I'm guessing that Ethan was love-bombing Erynn to get into her pants/make her his girlfriend, and Erynn loved the attention and compliments. She ignored the darker side of his personality until it was too late.
 
Last edited:

MiltonPowers

Twins Basil! Twins!
Donor
Jul 26, 2023
11,921
25,730
I think she saw a little kid that was clearly hurt and she went to console him as opposed to watching those two stand around and argue over dumb shit. Thats how I understood the scene. You're right she wasn't going into the house if he went in, but she likely went over to him as soon as she saw where he went.
If she deliberately was going to check up on him (and I suspect she wasn't), I believe she would never have mentioned it.

1, Ethan would have made fun of her, and

2, We see now how jealous Erynn gets of others around MC, she may have been the same back then and had a go at Lexi for talking to 'her' friend.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: LSC82

LSC82

Engaged Member
Jul 27, 2020
2,482
5,169
I think she saw a little kid that was clearly hurt and she went to console him as opposed to watching those two stand around and argue over dumb shit. Thats how I understood the scene. You're right she wasn't going into the house if he went in, but she likely went over to him as soon as she saw where he went.
We can argue wether she went after him or if she just left because the fight made her uncomfortable and happened to run into him by chance.
I lean towards the second one, her attitude prior to leaving just gives me the vibe she wouldn't leave if Erynn and Ethan don't get into a fight(if it ends fast, "ok i'll stop").
I think she stayed behind a good chunk of time after the dude legged it and only left after seeing the fight was going to be a long one.

And i don't think she had any reliable means of knowing where he stopped running, the MC starts running and she stays listening to Erynn and Ethan arguing for a some time before leaving(and she does so by walking), unless he stopped running still within eyesight...
Which i'm pretty sure he didn't, Ethan can still mock him if he is 20 meters away and within sight, and Erynn wouldn't need to explain that she was fighting with Ethan because he would've heard it... also Erynn and Ethan would have some reaction to the kiss.
 
Last edited:
4.40 star(s) 305 Votes