1) It is a cliché and I don't know if Nyx would go there.
2) Ethan was 15 when the MC was 12. How would that work?
3) Agreed but still a better (seeming) person than Mr Coleman.
On ethan I was ironic, in my native language (Italian) it would have been more understandable, I apologize.
On the other two, these are two clichés, I think that of the latin lover coach is worse, because it would give little space to a sequel, at 40 it is still there that the girls are banged in the locker room, difficult to believe there is a father-son storyline to be able to exploit.
Coleman seems like a bad person, but in reality, if I remember correctly, he is just a strict and dutiful person, here it would be easier to work on it, starting from his personality.
His attitude can derive precisely from having had a relationship with one of his students, a true and sincere relationship, but by all seen as scandalous, but above all something that did not respect the rules, he could have gone through a bad time for that relationship and this led him to be a fanatic of the rules, as well as making him angry for losing the girl he loved.
In conclusion, I would exclude the people on the plane, I think that was just a Nyx joke. The MC father will play a key role, and we still know little about the relationship between the mother and the adoptive father, was it the mother who asked for the separation after discovering she was a lesbian? Was there really a betrayal? What if Anders is an abusive husband?
Out of curiosity, I replayed and kept away from Alexis, Layla and Nikki. Now I don't know how I did it, but in this version if the MC is not with Nikki, the last night at his father's house, the latter has a bad argument with his new girlfriend and when the MC accuses him of cheating the mother, the father punches him, denying what happened.
I believe Anders left his wife when he found out that the MC was not his son, I don't think there was a betrayal on his part
Finally, in my second version I noticed that without the three girls mentioned above the plot is really unattractive, I hoped that by ignoring them I could get closer to Elena or Melissa, instead the only sex scenes or love interests, are simple escapades, with Rachel being fired and Tory then ignoring us. I don't know if there will be further additions to these two girls in the prox updates, but if not, I wouldn't miss them.
The story hinges on Nikki Alexis Eryn and Layla. I think it's all about them.